Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

I accept this policy

Find out more here

Ratio in subiecto? The Sources of Augustine’s Proof for the Immortality of the Soul in the Soliloquia and its Defense in De immortalitate animae

No metrics data to plot.
The attempt to load metrics for this article has failed.
The attempt to plot a graph for these metrics has failed.
The full text of this article is not currently available.

Brill’s MyBook program is exclusively available on BrillOnline Books and Journals. Students and scholars affiliated with an institution that has purchased a Brill E-Book on the BrillOnline platform automatically have access to the MyBook option for the title(s) acquired by the Library. Brill MyBook is a print-on-demand paperback copy which is sold at a favorably uniform low price.

Access this article

+ Tax (if applicable)
Add to Favorites
You must be logged in to use this functionality

image of Phronesis

This paper argues that Augustine did not take the proof in Soliloquia 2.22-4, which centers on the Aristotelian notion of ‘being in a subject’ (in subiecto esse), from a single source but constructed it in a deliberately imperfect manner from several passages from Porphyry’s works on Aristotle’s Categories in order to supplement it with further arguments in Book Three. In De immortalitate animae Augustine explicitly discloses the weaknesses of the proof and repairs them by means of a Neoplatonic notion of causality.

Affiliations: 1: Universität Würzburg, Institut für Klassische Philologie 97070 WürzburgGermany


Full text loading...


Data & Media loading...

1. Balido G."Agostino d’Ippona: De immortalitate animae—L’immortalità dell’anima"Introduzione, traduzione, note e appendice2010Naples
2. Barnes J."Porphyry: Introduction"Translated with an introduction and commentary2003Oxford
3. Bodéüs R.Porphyre: Commentaire aux Catégories d’Aristote2008ParisÉdition critique, traduction française, introduction et notes
4. Cary P."‘God in the Soul: Or, the Residue of Augustine’s Manichaean Optimism’"The University of Dayton Review1994Vol 226982
5. Cary P.Augustine’s Invention of the Inner Self2000Oxford
6. Catapano G.Agostino: Sull’anima: L’immortalità dell’anima. La grandezza dell’anima2003MilanTesto latino a fronte. Introduzione, traduzione, note e apparati
7. Catapano G.Agostino: Tutti i dialoghi2006MilanTesto latino a fronte. Introduzione generale, presentazioni ai dialoghi e note
8. Catapano G."‘Augustine’s Treatise De Immortalitate Animae and the Proof of the Soul’s Immortality in his Soliloquia’"Documenti e studi sulla tradizione filosofica medievale2014Vol 256784
9. Chiaradonna R."‘Essence et prédication chez Porphyre et Plotin’"Revue des Sciences philosophiques et théologiques1998Vol 82577606
10. Chiaradonna R."‘What is Porphyry’s Isagoge?’"Documenti e studi sulla tradizione filosofica medievale2008Vol 19130
11. Courcelle P.Les lettres grecques en occident de Macrobe à Cassiodore1948Paris
12. De Haas F. A. J.John Philoponus’ New Definition of Prime Matter: Aspects of its Background in Neoplatonism and the Ancient Commentary Tradition1997Leiden
13. Divjak J."‘Commonitorium’"Augustinus-Lexikon1986-1994Vol 110771079
14. Dörrie H.Porphyrios’ Symmikta Zetemata: Ihre Stellung in System und Geschichte des Neuplatonismus nebst einem Kommentar zu den Fragmenten1959Munich
15. Doucet D."‘La vérité, le vrai et la forme du corps. Lecture de saint Augustin: Soliloques ii, xviii, 32’"Revue des Sciences Philosophiques et Théologiques1993aVol 7754766
16. Doucet D."‘“Soliloques” ii,12,22: être dans un sujet’"Augustiniana1993bVol 434351
17. Doucet D."‘Augustin, “Confessions” iv, xvi, 28-29, “Soliloques” ii, xx, 34-36 et les “Commentaires des Catégories”’"Rivista di filosofia neo-scolastica2001Vol 93372392
18. Drecoll V. H.Die Entstehung der Gnadenlehre Augustins1999Tübingen
19. Drecoll V. H."‘Immortalitate animae (De—)’"Augustinus-Lexikon2004-2010Vol 3530535
20. Du Roy O.L’intelligence de la foi en la Trinité selon saint Augustin: Genèse de sa théologie trinitaire jusqu’au 3911966Paris
21. Griffin M. J.Aristotle’s Categories in the Early Roman Empire2015Oxford
22. Hadot I.Arts libéraux et philosophie dans la pensée antique1984Paris
23. Hadot P.Porphyre et Victorinus1968Paris
24. Henry P.Plotin et l’occident1934Louvain
25. Hörmann W."Augustinus: Soliloquiorum libri duo. De inmortalitate animae. De quantitate animae"Corpus Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum Latinorum1986Vol 89Vienna
26. Kalligas P. Fowden E. K., Pilavachi N.The Enneads of Plotinus: A Commentary2014Vol Vol. 1Princeton
27. Kany R.Augustins Trinitätsdenken: Bilanz, Kritik und Weiterführung der modernen Forschung zu ‘De trinitate’2007Tübingen
28. Karfíková L.Aurelius Augustinus: O nesmtelnosti duše2013aPraha
29. Karfíková L. Karfík F., Song E."‘Das Verhältnis von Seele und ratio in Augustins Abhandlung De immortalitate animae’"Plato Revived. Essays on Ancient Platonism in Honour of D. J. O’Meara2013bBerlin117137
30. Madec G. Reale G."‘Le spiritualisme augustinien à la lumière du De immortalitate animae’"L’opera letteraria di Agostino tra Cassiciacum e Milano1987Palermo179190
31. Madec G. Goulet-Cazé M.-O., Madec G., O’Brien D."‘Augustin et Porphyre: ébauche d’un bilan des recherches et des conjectures’"ΣΟΦΙΗΣ ΜΑΙΗΤΟΡΕΣ—Chercheurs de sagesse: Hommage à J. Pépin1992Paris367382
32. Marrou H.-I.Saint Augustin et la fin de la culture antique19584th ednParis
33. Mayer C."‘Creatio, creator, creatura’"Augustinus-Lexikon1996-2002Vol 256116
34. Mourant J. A.Augustine on Immortality1969The Saint Augustine Lecture 1968. Villanova.
35. Mourant J. A."‘Remarks on the “De Immortalitate Animae”’"Augustinian Studies1971Vol 2213217
36. Müller H.Augustins Soliloquien1954Diss. Basel.
37. O’Connell R. J.Saint Augustine’s Early Theory of Man, A.D. 386-3911968Cambridge
38. O’Connell R. J."‘Pre-Existence in the Early Augustine’"Revue des Études Augustiniennes1980Vol 26176188
39. O’Daly G. J. P."‘Did St. Augustine ever believe in the Soul’s Pre-existence?’"Augustinian Studies1974Vol 5227235
40. Pépin J."‘Une nouvelle source de saint Augustin: le ζήτηµα de Porphyre “Sur l’union de l’âme et du corps”’"Revue des Études Anciennes1964Vol 6653107[Reprinted as ‘L’influence de Porphyre sur la doctrine de l’âme et la théologie trinitaire de saint Augustin’ in Pépin, Ex Platonicorum persona. Études sur les lectures philosophiques de saint Augustin, Amsterdam 1977, 213-67.]
41. Pépin M.Augustin d’Hippone: De immortalitate animae1984Diss. Paris.
42. Smith A.Porphyrius: Fragmenta1993Stuttgart / Leipzig
43. Sorabji R."The Philosophy of the Commentators 200-600 AD. A Soucebook"Logic and Metaphysics2004Vol Vol. 3London
44. Strange S. K.Porphyry: On Aristotle’s Categories1992London
45. Theiler W.Porphyrios und Augustin1933Halle
46. Tornau C.Plotin: Enneaden VI 4-5 [22-23]. Ein Kommentar1998Stuttgart / Leipzig
47. Verbeke G."‘Spiritualité et immortalité de l’âme chez saint Augustin’"Augustinus Magister: Congrès international augustinien, Paris, 21-24 septembre 19541954Vol vol. 1Paris329334
48. Watson G.Saint Augustine: Soliloquies and Immortality of the Soul1990WarminsterWith an introduction, translation and commentary
49. Wolfskeel C. W.Augustine: De immortalitate animae1977AmsterdamText, translation and commentary

Article metrics loading...



Can't access your account?
  • Tools

  • Add to Favorites
  • Printable version
  • Email this page
  • Subscribe to ToC alert
  • Get permissions
  • Recommend to your library

    You must fill out fields marked with: *

    Librarian details
    Your details
    Why are you recommending this title?
    Select reason:
    Phronesis — Recommend this title to your library
  • Export citations
  • Key

  • Full access
  • Open Access
  • Partial/No accessInformation