Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

I accept this policy

Find out more here

The Economics of the Right to Keep a Dog

No metrics data to plot.
The attempt to load metrics for this article has failed.
The attempt to plot a graph for these metrics has failed.
The full text of this article is not currently available.

Brill’s MyBook program is exclusively available on BrillOnline Books and Journals. Students and scholars affiliated with an institution that has purchased a Brill E-Book on the BrillOnline platform automatically have access to the MyBook option for the title(s) acquired by the Library. Brill MyBook is a print-on-demand paperback copy which is sold at a favorably uniform low price.

Access this article

+ Tax (if applicable)
Add to Favorites
You must be logged in to use this functionality

A Case Study of a Private Housing Complex in Hong Kong

image of Society & Animals

Dog guardianship has gained popularity in many cities as a result of animal domestication. In spite of its benefits, dog guardianship in high-density urban housing creates certain problems, including increased health risks. Conflicts between different interested parties over the right to keep dogs have therefore surfaced. In Hong Kong, a lawsuit was initiated by a resident in a private housing estate, Mei Foo Sun Chuen, to overturn dog bans imposed by the property management company. The court’s judgment stated that dog bans are enforceable only if dogs are explicitly prohibited in the deed of mutual covenant. This study aims to value empirically the right to keep dogs in private housing based on an analysis of a set of housing transaction data in Hong Kong. It also investigates how the value of the right has changed with the court judgment. The findings suggest that the right was negatively valued by the market, but the court judgment increased its value. These results demonstrate a revealed preference of the Hong Kong community for dog guardianship in a high-rise living environment.

Affiliations: 1: City University of Hong Kong ; 2: The University of Hong Kong


Full text loading...


Data & Media loading...

1. Agriculture and Fisheries Department "Concerns raised at the meeting on 23 July 1999 which require follow up actions by the administration" 1999 Retrieved from
2. Alie K. , David B. W. , Fielding W. J. , Maldonado F. G. "Attitudes towards dogs and other ‘pets’ in Roseau, Dominica" Anthrozoös 2007 Vol 20 2 143 154
3. Anderson W. P. , Reid C. M. , Jennings G. L. "Pet ownership and risk factors for cardiovascular disease" Medical Journal of Australia 1992 Vol 157 5 298 301
4. Avner J. R. , Baker M. D. "Dog bites in urban children" Pediatrics 1991 Vol 88 1 55 57
5. Bakke J. V. , Norbäck D. , Wieslander G. , Hollund B. E. , Moen B. E. "Pet keeping and dampness in the dwelling: Associations with airway infections, symptoms, and physiological signs from the ocular and nasal mucosa" Indoor Air 2007 Vol 17 1 60 69
6. Banks M. R. , Banks W. A. "The effects of groups and individual animal-assisted therapy on loneliness in residents of long-term care facilities" Anthrozoös 2005 Vol 18 4 396 408
7. Beck A. M. , Katcher A. H. Between pets and people: The importance of animal companionship 1996 West Lafayette, IL Purdue University Press
8. Benfield R. , Plurad D. S. , Lam L. , Talving P. , Green D. J. , Putty B. "The epidemiology of dog attacks in an urban environment and the risk of vascular injury" The American Surgeon 2010 Vol 76 2 203 205
9. Bjerke T. , Østdahl T. "Animal-related attitudes and activities an urban population" Anthrozoös 2004 Vol 17 2 109 129
10. Bradley J. Dog bites—problems and solutions 2006 Baltimore, MD Animals and Society Institute [Policy paper]
11. Brodie S. J. , Biley F. C. "An exploration of the potential benefits of pet-facilitated therapy" Journal of Clinical Nursing 1999 Vol 8 4 329 337
12. Brown S. G. , Rhodes R. E. "Relationships among dog ownership and leisure-time walking in Western Canadian adults" American Journal of Preventive Medicine 2006 Vol 30 2 131 136
13. Carlisle-Frank P. , Frank J. M. , Nielsen L. "Companion animal renters and pet-friendly housing in the us " Anthrozoös 2005 Vol 18 1 59 77
14. Chau K. W. , Ma S. M. , Ho D. C. W. "The pricing of ‘luckiness’ in the apartment market" Journal of Real Estate Literature 2001 Vol 9 1 31 40
15. China Daily "Insult to dog triggers attack" 2011 May 12 [Hong Kong Edition] p. H01
16. Cline K. M. C. "Psychological effects of dog ownership: Role strain, role enhancement, and depression" The Journal of Social Psychology 2010 Vol 150 2 117 131
17. Court A. T. General Motors Corporation "Hedonic price index with automotive examples" The dynamics of automobile demand 1939 New York, NY General Motors Corporation 98 119
18. Cropper M. L. , Deck L. B. , McConnell K. E. "On the choice of functional form for hedonic price functions" Review of Economics and Statistics 1988 Vol 70 4 668 675
19. DeMello L. R. "The effect of the presence of a companion-animal on physiological changes following the termination of cognitive stressors" Psychology and Health 1999 Vol 14 5 859 868
20. Dong G. H. , Ma Y. N. , Ding H. L. , Jin J. , Cao Y. , Zhao Y. D. , He Q. C. "Effects of housing characteristics and home environmental factors on respiratory symptoms of 10,784 elementary school children from Northeast China" Respiration 2008 Vol 75 1 82 91
21. Dublin City Council "Ban on certain breeds of dogs" 2007 Retrieved from
22. Dumont G. "A telephone survey on attitudes of pet owners and non-owners to dogs and cats in Belgian cities" Anthrozoös 1996 Vol 9 1 19 24
23. Fielding W. J. "Dogs: A continuing and common neighbourhood nuisance of New Providence, The Bahamas" Society & Animals 2008 Vol 16 1 61 73
24. Fielding W. J. , Mather J. "Dog ownership in the West Indies: A case study from The Bahamas" Anthrozoös 2001 Vol 14 2 72 80
25. Franklin A. Animals and modern cultures 1999 London, United Kingdom Sage
26. Franklin A. "“Be[a]ware of the dog”: A post-humanist approach to housing" Housing, Theory and Society 2006 Vol 23 3 137 156
27. Friedmann E. , Thomas S. A. Wilson C. C. , Turner D. C. "Pet ownership, social support, and one-year survival after acute myocardial infarction in the cardiac arrhythmia suppression trial ( cast)" Companion animals in human health 1998 Thousand Oaks, CA Sage Publications 187 201
28. Frischmann C. Pets and the planet: A practical guide to sustainable pet care 2009 Hoboken, NJ Wiley
29. Garrity T. F. , Stallones L. , Marx M. B. , Johnson T. P. "Pet ownership and attachment as supportive factors in the health of the elderly" Anthrozoös 1989 Vol 3 1 35 44
30. Gray P. B. , Young S. M. "Human-pet dynamics in cross-cultural perspective" Anthrozoös 2011 Vol 24 1 17 30
31. Griliches Z. Price indexes and quality change 1971 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press
32. Headey B. National people and pets survey 2006—socially responsible pet ownership in Australia: A decade of progress 2006 South Yarra, Australia Petcare Information and Advisory Service
33. Ho S. "Dog owners fail to overturn ban" The Standard 2010 August 6 P06
34. Hong Kong Housing Authority Pet keeping in public housing estates: Memorandum for the Subsidised Housing Committee, The Hong Kong Housing Authority, paper no. shc35/2003 2003 Hong Kong Hong Kong Housing Authority
35. Hughes W. T. , Turnbull G. K. "Restrictive land covenants" Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 1996a Vol 12 1 9 21
36. Hughes W. T. , Turnbull G. K. "Uncertain neighborhood effects and restrictive covenants" Journal of Urban Economics 1996b Vol 39 2 160 172
37. Huss R. J. "No pets allowed: Housing issues and companion animals" Animal Law 2005 Vol 11 69 130
38. Jason L. A. , McCoy K. , Blanco D. , Zolik E. S. "Decreasing dog litter: Behavioural consultation to help a community group" Evaluation Review 1980 Vol 4 3 355 369
39. Katcher A. H. "Are companion animals good for your health?" Aging 1982 Vol 331/332 5 2 8
40. Lancaster K. J. "A new approach to consumer theory" Journal of Political Economy 1966 Vol 74 2 132 156
41. Libecap G. D. Contracting for property rights 1989 New York, NY Cambridge University Press
42. Mayor’s Alliance for nyc’s Animals "New York City Housing Authority ( nycha) dog owning tenants’ rights" 2011 Retrieved from
43. Miura A. , Bradshaw J. W. S. , Tanida H. "Attitudes towards dogs: A study of university students in Japan and the uk " Anthrozoös 2000 Vol 13 2 80 88
44. Mok H. M. K. "A hedonic approach to pricing of residential properties in Hong Kong" Hong Kong Journal of Business Management 1995 Vol 13 1 1 15
45. Mok H. M. K. , Chan P. P. K. , Cho Y. S. "A hedonic price model for private properties in Hong Kong" Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 1995 Vol 10 1 37 48
46. Munsell K. L. , Canfield M. , Templer D. I. , Tangan K. , Arikawa H. "Modification of the pet attitude scale" Society & Animals 2004 Vol 12 2 137 142
47. New York City Housing Authority "Pet policy overview" 2010 Retrieved from
48. Nip A. " hosflat owners challenge dog ban" South China Morning Post 2010 March 15 City, p. 1
49. Rating and Valuation Department "Private domestic—Price indices for selected popular developments (from 1992)" 2011 Retrieved from
50. Rogers J. , Hart L. A. , Boltz R. P. "The role of pet dogs in casual conversations of elderly adults" The Journal of Social Psychology 1993 Vol 133 3 265 277
51. Rogers W. H. "A market for institutions: Assessing the impact of restrictive covenants on housing" Land Economics 2006 Vol 82 4 500 512
52. Rogers W. H. "The housing price impact of covenant restrictions and other subdivision characteristics" Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 2010 Vol 40 2 203 220
53. Rosen S. "Hedonic prices and the implicit markets: Product differentiation in pure competition" Journal of Political Economy Vol 82 1 132 157
54. Ryan B. D. , Weber R. "Valuing new development in distressed urban neighborhoods: Does design matter?" Journal of the American Planning Association 2007 Vol 73 1 100 111
55. Sabloff A. Reordering the natural world: Humans and animals in the city 2001 Toronto, Canada University of Toronto Press
56. Sacks J. J. , Kresnow M. , Houston B. "Dog bites: How big a problem?" Injury Prevention 1996 Vol 2 1 52 54
57. Schaffner J. "Ensuring a “yes-pets” rule" 2007 Retrieved from
58. Serpell J. A. "Factors influencing human attitudes to animals and their welfare" Animal Welfare 2004 Vol 13 1 145 151
59. Siegel J. M. "Stressful life events and use of physician services among the elderly: The moderating role of pet ownership" Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1990 Vol 58 6 1081 1086
60. Signal T. D. , Taylor N. "Attitudes to animals: Demographics within a community sample" Society & Animals 2006 Vol 14 2 147 157
61. So H. M. , Tse R. Y. C. , Ganesan S. "Estimating the influence of transport on house prices: Evidence from Hong Kong" Journal of Property Valuation and Investment 1997 Vol 15 1 40 47
62. Social Sciences Research Centre Personal and environmental hygiene survey (dengue fever and sars)—main report 2004 Hong Kong Central Health Education Unit, Department of Health
63. South China Morning Post "Animal attack" 2007 August 6 City, p. 1
64. Speyrer J. F. "The effect of land-use restrictions on market values of single-family homes in Houston" Journal Real Estate Finance and Economics 1989 Vol 2 2 117 130
65. Takkouche B. , González-Barcala F. J. , Etminan M. , FitzGerald M. "Exposure to furry pets and the risk of asthma and allergic rhinitis: A meta-analysis" Allergy 2008 Vol 63 7 857 864
66. Tse R. Y. C. , Love P. E. D. "Measuring residential property values in Hong Kong" Property Management 2000 Vol 18 5 366 374
67. Utley W. A. , Buller I. B. "A study of complaints about noise from domestic premises" Journal of Sound and Vibration 1988 Vol 127 2 319 330
68. Wood L. J. , Giles B. , Bulsara M. K. , Bosch D. A. "More than a furry companion: The ripple effect of companion animals on neighborhood interactions and sense of community" Society & Animals 2007 Vol 15 1 43 56
69. Yiu C. Y. , Wong S. K. "The effects of expected transport improvements on housing prices" Urban Studies 2005 Vol 42 1 113 125

Article metrics loading...



Can't access your account?
  • Tools

  • Add to Favorites
  • Printable version
  • Email this page
  • Subscribe to ToC alert
  • Get permissions
  • Recommend to your library

    You must fill out fields marked with: *

    Librarian details
    Your details
    Why are you recommending this title?
    Select reason:
    Society & Animals — Recommend this title to your library
  • Export citations
  • Key

  • Full access
  • Open Access
  • Partial/No accessInformation