Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

I accept this policy

Find out more here

Academic “Dirty Work”

No metrics data to plot.
The attempt to load metrics for this article has failed.
The attempt to plot a graph for these metrics has failed.
The full text of this article is not currently available.

Brill’s MyBook program is exclusively available on BrillOnline Books and Journals. Students and scholars affiliated with an institution that has purchased a Brill E-Book on the BrillOnline platform automatically have access to the MyBook option for the title(s) acquired by the Library. Brill MyBook is a print-on-demand paperback copy which is sold at a favorably uniform low price.

Access this article

+ Tax (if applicable)
Add to Favorites
You must be logged in to use this functionality

Mapping Scholarly Labor in a Tainted Mixed-Species Field

image of Society & Animals

Human-Animal Studies ( has) is an innovative field, tarnished by its politicized mixed-species subject matter. This paper considers how nonhuman animal scholars may also be tainted, for different reasons and to varying degrees, because of the academic “dirty work” they perform within has. As the field matures, tensions are emerging among this disparate scholarly group. These tensions are associated with the rise of Critical Animal Studies ( cas), the extent to which animal scholars should engage in emancipatory-type scholarship and the appearance of the “animal as such–animal as constructed” axis within has. This paper draws on these intrafield tensions to form a potential framework that maps scholarly labor within has. As scholars begin to debate what counts as “good” and “bad” human-animal scholarship, this may engender the appearance of academic-moral havens. It is suggested that such enclaves may partly mitigate the personal challenges and professional stigma of working in a tarnished academic field.

Affiliations: 1: School of Social Science (Sociology), University of Aberdeen


Full text loading...


Data & Media loading...

1. Aaltola E. "The philosophy behind the movement: Animal studies versus animal rights" Society & Animals 2011 Vol 19 4 393 406
2. Abbott A. "Status and status strain in the professions" American Journal of Sociology 1981 Vol 86 4 819 835
3. Ackroyd S. , Crowdy P. "Can culture be managed? Working with “raw” material: The case of English slaughtermen" Personnel Review 2007 Vol 19 5 3 13
4. Animals Liberation Philosophy and Policy JournalEditorial Board "The history and philosophy of the Center on Animal Liberation Affairs" Animal Liberation Philosophy and Policy Journal 2003 Vol 1 1 1 3 Retrieved August 15, 2012, from
5. Appell G. "Talking ethics: The uses of moral rhetoric and the function of ethical principles" Social Problems 1980 Vol 27 3 350 357
6. Arluke A. "Sacrificial symbolism in animal experimentation: Object or pet?" Anthrozoös 1988 Vol 2 2 98 117
7. Arluke A. "Going into the closet with science: Information control among animal experimenters" Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 1991 Vol 20 3 306 330
8. Arluke A. Manning A. , Serpell J. "Managing emotions in an animal shelter" Animals and human society. Changing perspectives 1994 London, United Kingdom Routledge 145 165
9. Arluke A. "A sociology of sociological animal studies" Society & Animals 2002 Vol 10 4 369 374
10. Arluke A. , Sanders C. Regarding animals 1996 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press
11. Arluke A. , Sanders C. Between the species. Readings in human-animal relations 2009 Boston, MA Pearson
12. Armstrong P. , Simmons L. Simmons L. , Armstrong P. "Bestiary: An introduction" Knowing animals 2007 Boston, MA Brill 1 24
13. Ashforth B. , Kreiner G. "“How can you do it?”: Dirty work and the challenge of constructing a positive identity" The Academy of Management Review 1999 Vol 24 3 413 434
14. Baker S. Picturing the beast: Animals, identity and representation 1993 Manchester, United Kingdom Manchester University Press
15. Bauman Z. , May T. Thinking sociologically 2001 Oxford, United Kingdom Blackwell Publishers
16. Best S. "Common natures, shared fates: Toward an interspecies alliance politics" 2002/2003 Retrieved April 9, 2012, from
17. Best S. "Rethinking revolution: Animal liberation, human liberation, and the future of the left" The International Journal of Inclusive Democracy 2006 Vol 2 3 1 24
18. Best S. "The rise of critical animal studies: Putting theory into action and animal liberation into higher education" Journal for Critical Animal Studies 2009 Vol 7 1 9 54
19. Birke L. Taylor N. , Signal T. "In hope of change: Rethinking human-animal relations?" Theorizing animals. Re-thinking humanimal relations 2011 Leiden, The Netherlands Brill xvii xx
20. Birke L. , Arluke A. , Michael M. The sacrifice: How scientific experiments transform animals and people 2007 West Lafayette, IN Purdue University Press
21. Bryant C. "The zoological connection: Animal-related human behaviour" Social Forces 1979 Vol 58 2 399 421
22. Carter B. , Charles N. Human and other animals. Critical perspectives 2011 Hampshire, United Kingdom Palgrave Macmillan
23. Convery I. , Bailey C. , Mort M. , Baxter J. "Death in the wrong place? Emotional geographies of the uk2001 foot and mouth disease epidemic" Journal of Rural Studies 2005 Vol 21 1 99 109
24. Cudworth E. Social lives with other animals. Tales of sex, death and love 2011 Hampshire, United Kingdom Palgrave Macmillan
25. Davis D. "Good people doing dirty work: A study of social isolation" Symbolic Interaction 1984 Vol 7 2 233 247
26. DeMello M. DeMello M. "Introduction to human-animal studies" Teaching the animal. Human-animal studies across the disciplines 2010 Brooklyn, NY Lantern Books xi xix
27. Dogan M. , Pahre R. " Creative marginality " Innovation at the intersections of social sciences 1990 Boulder, CO Westview Press
28. Dogan M. "The new social sciences: Cracks in the disciplinary walls" International Social Science Journal 1997 Vol 49 153 429 443
29. Dogan M. " Purity and danger " An analysis of the concepts of pollution and taboo 1966 London, United Kingdom Routledge
30. Drew S. , Mills M. Drew S. , Mills M. , Gassaway B. "Ethnography as dirty work" Dirty work. The social construction of taint 2007 Waco, TX Baylor University Press 217 231
31. Franklin A. Animals and modern cultures: A sociology of human-animal relations in modernity 1999 London, United Kingdom Sage
32. Fraser D. "The “new perception” of animal agriculture: Legless cows, featherless chickens, and a need for genuine analysis" Journal of Animal Science 2001 Vol 79 3 634 641
33. Gaard G. " Ecofeminism " Women, animals and nature 1993 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press
34. Gans H. "Public ethnography; Ethnography as public sociology" Qualitative Sociology 2010 Vol 33 1 97 104
35. Goffman E. Stigma: Notes on the management of spoiled identity 1963 London, United Kingdom Penguin Books
36. Haines H. "Black radicalization and the funding of civil rights: 1957-1970" Social Problems 1984 Vol 32 1 31 43
37. Hamilton L. "Muck and magic: Cultural transformations in the world of farm animal veterinary surgeons" Ethnography 2007 Vol 8 4 485 501
38. Henshaw D. " Animal warfare " The story of the animal liberation front 1989 London, United Kingdom Fontana
39. Holloway L. "Pets and protein: Placing domestic livestock on hobby-farms in England and Wales" Journal of Rural Studies 2001 Vol 17 3 293 307
40. Holloway L. "Smallholding, hobby-farming, and commercial farming: Ethical identities and the production of farming spaces" Environment and Planning A 2002 Vol 34 11 2055 2070
41. Hughes E. Men and their work 1958 Glencoe, IL The Free Press
42. Hughes E. " The sociological eye " Selected papers 1971 Chicago, IL Aldine Atherton
43. Humphrey N. "Histories" Social Research 1995 Vol 62 3 477 479
44. Humphries B. "From critical thought to emancipatory action: Contradictory research goals?" Sociological Research Online 1997 Vol 2 1 1 10 Retrieved April 30, 2012, from
45. Institute for Critical Animal Studies "About" 2012 Retrieved August 15, 2012, from
46. Institute for Critical Animal Studies Board of Directors "The Institute for Critical Animal Studies ( icas) Report—October 2009" Journal for Critical Animal Studies 2009 Vol vii ii 3 5
47. Kahn R. Nocella A. II , Best S. , McLaren P. "Operation get fired. A chronicle of the academic repression of radical environmentalist and animal rights advocate-scholars" Academic repression. Reflections from the academic industrial complex 2010 Oakland, CA AK Press 200 215
48. Kruse C. "Social animals: Animal studies and sociology" Society & Animals 2002 Vol 10 4 375 379
49. Laumann E. , Heinz J. "Specialization and prestige in the legal profession: The structure of deference" American Bar Foundation Research Journal 1977 Vol 2 1 155 216
50. Lundblad M. "From animal to animal studies" pmla 2009 Vol 124 2 496 502
51. Meara H. "Honor in dirty work: The case of American meat cutters and Turkish butchers" Work & Occupations 1974 Vol 1 3 259 283
52. Mills C. W. "Situated actions and the vocabularies of motive" American Sociological Review 1940 Vol 5 6 904 913
53. Mills M. , Drew S. , Gassaway B. Drew S. , Mills M. , Gassaway B. "Introduction" Dirty work. The social construction of taint 2007 Waco, TX Baylor University Press 1 7
54. Mills M. , Schejbal A. Drew S. , Mills M. , Gassaway B. "Bedpans, blood, and bile: Doing the dirty work in nursing" Dirty work. The social construction of taint 2007 Waco, TX Baylor University Press 113 131
55. Morris P. " Blue juice " Euthanasia in veterinary medicine 2012 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press
56. Nocella A. II "Challenging whiteness in the animal advocacy movement" Journal for Critical Animal Studies 2012 Vol 10 1 142 154
57. Peggs K. Animals and sociology 2012 Hampshire, United Kingdom Palgrave Macmillan
58. Rollin B. Farm animal welfare: Social bioethical, and research issues 1995 Ames, IA Iowa State University Press
59. Sanbonmatsu J. Critical theory and animal liberation 2011 Lanham, MD Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
60. Sanders C. "Killing with kindness: Veterinary euthanasia and the social construction of personhood" Sociological Forum 1995 Vol 10 2 195 214
61. Sanders C. "“The dog you deserve”: Ambivalence in the k-9 officer/patrol dog relationship" Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 2006 Vol 35 2 148 172
62. Sanders C. Hillyard S. "Ethnography as dangerous, sad, and dirty work" New frontiers in ethnography. Studies in qualitative methodology 2010a Vol Volume 11 Bingley, United Kingdom Emerald Group Publishing Limited 101 124
63. Sanders C. "Working out back: The veterinary technician and “dirty work”" Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 2010b Vol 39 3 243 272
64. Scott M. , Lyman S. "Accounts" American Sociological Review 1968 Vol 33 1 46 62
65. Shapiro K. Human-animal studies: Growing the field, applying the field 2008 Ann Arbor, MI Animals and Society Institute
66. Shapiro K. , DeMello M. "The state of human-animal studies" Society & Animals 2010 Vol 18 3 307 318
67. Sykes G. , Matza D. "Techniques of neutralization: A theory of delinquency" American Sociological Review 1957 Vol 22 6 664 670
68. Stallwood K. "Critical animal studies conference report" 2010 Retrieved March 28, 2012, from
69. Taylor N. , Signal T. " Theorizing animals " Re-thinking humanimal relations 2011 Leiden, The Netherlands Brill
70. Thompson W. "Hanging tongues: A sociological encounter with the assembly line" Qualitative Sociology 1983 Vol 6 3 215 237
71. Tracy S. , Scott C. Drew S. , Mills M. , Gassaway B. "Dirty work and discipline behind bars" Dirty work. The social construction of taint 2007 Waco, TX Baylor University Press 33 53
72. Tuan Y. Dominance and affection: The making of pets 1984 New Haven, CT Yale University Press
73. Turner J. The structure of sociological theory 1991 Belmont, CA Wadsworth Publishing Company
74. Twine R. " Animals as biotechnology " Ethics, sustainability and critical animal studies 2010 London, United Kingdom Earthscan
75. Whatmore S. "Materialist returns: Practising cultural geography in and for a more-than-human world" Cultural Geographies 2006 Vol 13 4 632 636
76. Wilkie R. Livestock/deadstock: Working with farm animals from birth to slaughter 2010 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press
77. Williams A. "Disciplining animals: Sentience, production, and critique" International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 2004 Vol 24 9 45 57
78. Zerubavel E. "The rigid, the fuzzy, and the flexible: Notes on the mental sculpting of academic identity" Social Research 1995 Vol 62 4 1093 1106

Article metrics loading...



Can't access your account?
  • Tools

  • Add to Favorites
  • Printable version
  • Email this page
  • Subscribe to ToC alert
  • Get permissions
  • Recommend to your library

    You must fill out fields marked with: *

    Librarian details
    Your details
    Why are you recommending this title?
    Select reason:
    Society & Animals — Recommend this title to your library
  • Export citations
  • Key

  • Full access
  • Open Access
  • Partial/No accessInformation