Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

I accept this policy

Find out more here

Does Situationism Threaten Free Will and Moral Responsibility?

No metrics data to plot.
The attempt to load metrics for this article has failed.
The attempt to plot a graph for these metrics has failed.
The full text of this article is not currently available.

Brill’s MyBook program is exclusively available on BrillOnline Books and Journals. Students and scholars affiliated with an institution that has purchased a Brill E-Book on the BrillOnline platform automatically have access to the MyBook option for the title(s) acquired by the Library. Brill MyBook is a print-on-demand paperback copy which is sold at a favorably uniform low price.

Access this article

+ Tax (if applicable)
Add to Favorites
You must be logged in to use this functionality

image of Journal of Moral Philosophy

The situationist movement in social psychology has caused a considerable stir in philosophy. Much of this was prompted by the work of Gilbert Harman and John Doris. Both contended that familiar philosophical assumptions about the role of character in the explanation of action were not supported by experimental results. Most of the ensuing philosophical controversy has focused upon issues related to moral psychology and ethical theory. More recently, the influence of situationism has also given rise to questions regarding free will and moral responsibility. There is cause for concern that a range of situationist findings are in tension with the reasons-responsiveness putatively required for free will and moral responsibility. We develop and defend a response to the alleged situationist threat to free will and moral responsibility that we call pessimistic realism. We conclude on an optimistic note, exploring the possibility of strengthening our agency in the face of situational influences.

Affiliations: 1: Department of Philosophy, University of Arizona, ; 2: Department of Philosophy, Bowling Green State University,


Full text loading...


Data & Media loading...

1. Asch Solomon,. 1951. “"Effects of Group Pressures upon the Modification and Distortion of Judgment".” In Groups, Leadership, Men . Ed., Guetzkow Harold. Pittsburgh: Carnegie Press: 17790.
2. Bargh John A.,, and Ferguson M.J.. 2000. "Beyond Behaviorism: On the Automaticity of Higher Mental Processes". Psychological Bulletin Vol 126 (6 Special Issue): 92545.
3. Blass T. 1996. “"Attribution of Responsibility and Trust in the Milgram Obedience Experiment",” Journal of Applied Social Psychology Vol 26:15291535.
4. Bowers K. 1973. “"Situationism in Psychology: An Analysis and a Critique",” Psychological Review Vol 80: 30736.
5. Brink David. 2013. “"Situationism, Responsibility, and Fair Opportunity",” Social Philosophy and Policy Vol 30: 121149.
6. Brink David, and Nelkin Dana,. 2013. "“Fairness and the Architecture of Responsibility.”" In Shoemaker David, ed., Oxford Studies in Agency and Responsibility . Vol. Vol 1 Oxford: Oxford University Press: 284313.
7. Burton R. 1963. “"Generality of Honesty Reconsidered",” Psychological Review Vol 70: 481499.
8. Ciurria Michelle. 2013. “"Situationism, Moral Responsibility and Blame",” Philosophia Vol 41: 179193.
9. Darley J. 1995. “"Constructive and Destructive Disobedience: A Taxonomy of Principal-Agent Relationships",” Journal of Social Issues Vol 51: 125154.
10. Darley J., and Batson C.. 1973. “"‘From Jerusalem to Jericho:’ A Study of Situational and Dispositional Variables in Helping Behavior",” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology Vol 27: 100108.
11. Dennett Daniel. 1984. Elbow Room: Varieties of Free Will Worth Wanting . Cambridge, ma: mit Press.
12. Doris John. 2002. Lack of Character . Cambridge, Mass.: Cambridge University Press.
13. Doris J., and Murphy D. 2007. “"From My Lai to Abu Ghraib: The Moral Psychology of Atrocity",” Midwest Studies in Philosophy Vol 31: 2555.
14. Elms A. 1995. “"Obedience in Retrospect",” Journal of Social Issues Vol 51: 2131.
15. Epstein S. 1979. “The Stability of Behavior: i. On Predicting Most of the People Much of the Time,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology Vol 37: 1097126.
16. Fischer John Martin, and Ravizza Mark. 1998. Responsibility and Control: An Essay on Moral Responsibility . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
17. Gert Bernard, and Duggan Tim. 1979. “"Free Will as the Ability to Will",” Nous Vol 13: 197217.
18. Goldhagen D. 1996. Hitler’s Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust . Knopf, New York.
19. Gollwitzer P. 1999. “"Implementation Intentions",” American Psychologist Vol 54: 307316.
20. Gollwitzer P., and Sheeran P.. 2006. “"Implementation Intentions and Global Achievement: A Meta-Analysis of Effects and Processes",” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology Vol 38: 69119.
21. Haji Ishtiyaque. 1998. Moral Appraisability . New York: Oxford University Press.
22. Haney Craig,, Banks Curtis, and Zimbardo Philip. 1973. “"Interpersonal Dynamics in a Simulated Prison".” International Journal of Criminology and Penology.Vol 1: 6997.
23. Haney C., and Zimbardo P. 1998. “The Past and Future of u.s. Prison Policy: Twenty-five Years after the Stanford Prison Experiment,” American Psychologist Vol 53: 709727.
24. Harman Gilbert. 1999. “"Moral Psychology Meets Social Psychology: Virtue Ethics and the Fundamental Attribution Error".” Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society Vol 99: 31531.
25. Isen A., and Levin P.. 1972. “"Effect of Feeling Good on Helping: Cookies and Kindness",” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology Vol 21: 384388.
26. Kamtekar Rachana. 2004. "Situationism and Virtue Ethics on the Content of Our Character". Ethics Vol 114: 45891.
27. Kihlstrom John F., 2008. The Automaticity Juggernaut – Or, Are We Automatons After All? In Are We Free? Psychology and Free Will , edited by Baer John,, Kaufman James C.,, and Baumeister Roy F.. New York: Oxford University Press.
28. Latane B., and Darley J. 1970. Unresponsive Behavior – Why doesn’t he help? New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
29. Latané B., and Rodin J.. 1969. “"A Lady in Distress: Inhibiting Effects of Friends and Strangers on Bystander Intervention",” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology Vol 5: 189202.
30. Lutsky N. 1995. When is ‘obedience’ Obedience? Conceptual and Historical Commentary, Journal of Social Issues Vol 51: 5565.
31. McKenna Michael. forthcoming. “"Reasons-Responsive Theories of Freedom".” Routledge Handbook on Free Will . Routledge Press.
32. McKenna Michael,. 2013. “"Reasons-Responsiveness, Agents, and Mechanisms".” In Shoemaker David, ed., 2013. Oxford Studies in Agency and Responsibility , vol. Vol 1. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 15184.
33. Mele Alfred. 1995. Autonomous Agents . New York: Oxford University Press.
34. Mele Alfred, and Shepherd Joshua. 2013. “"Situation and Agency".” Journal of Practical Ethics Vol 1: 6283.
35. Milgram S. 1969. Obedience to Authority , New York: Harper & Row.
36. Miller A. 1995. “"Constructions of the Obedience Experiments: A Focus Upon Domains of Relevance",” Journal of Social Issues Vol 51: 3353.
37. Miller Christian B. 2013. Moral Character: An Empirical Theory , Oxford: Oxford University Press.
38. Miller Christian B. 2014. Character and Moral Psychology , Oxford: Oxford University Press.
39. Miller Christian B,. 2016. "“Situationism and Free Will,”" Rutledge Companion to Free Will , Ed. Griffith Meghan,, Timpe Kevin,, and Levy Neil. Routledge.
40. Miller Christian B., forthcoming. “"Virtue Cultivation in Light of Situationism",” in Annas Julia,, Snow Nancy,, and Narvaez Darcia, Developing the Virtues: Integrating Perspectives . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
41. Modigliani A.,, Rochat F. 1995. “"The Role of Interaction Sequences and the Timing of Resistance in Shaping Obedience and Defiance to Authority".,” Journal of Social Issues Vol 51: 107123.
42. Nahmias Eddy,. 2007. “"Autonomous Agency and Social Psychology".” In De Caro Maraffa,, and Ferriti, Eds., Cartographies of the Mind , Vol. Vol 4, Dordrecht: Springer: 16985.
43. Nelkin Dana. 2011. Making Sense of Freedom and Responsibility . Oxford University Press.
44. Nelkin Dana. 2005. “"Freedom, Responsibility, and the Challenge of Situationism".” Midwest Studies in Philosophy Vol 29: 181206.
45. Newcomb T. 1929. Consistency of Certain Extrovert-introvert Behavior Patterns in 51 Problem Boys . Columbia University, Teachers College, Bureau of Publications, New York.
46. Pereboom Derk. 2001. Living Without Free Will . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
47. Pereboom Derk. 2014. Free Will, Agency, and Meaning in Life . New York: Oxford University Press.
48. Rochat F., and Modigliani A. 1995. “"The Ordinary Quality of Resistance: From Milgram’s Laboratory to the Village of Le Chambon",” Journal of Social Issues Vol 51: 195210.
49. Rodgers Travis, and Warmke Brandon. 2015. “"Situationism versus Situationism",” Ethical Theory and Moral Practice Vol 18: 926.
50. Rosenthal A. 1999. Thirty-eight Witnesses: The Kitty Genevese Case , 2nd edn. Berkeley: University of California Press.
51. Ross L., and Nisbett R.. 1991. The Person and the Situation: Perspectives of Social Psychology , New York: McGraw-Hill.
52. Russell Daniel. 2009. Practical Intelligence and the Virtues , Oxford: Clarendon Press.
53. Russell Paul,. provisionally forthcoming. “"Free Will Pessimism".” In Shoemaker David, ed., 2016. Oxford Studies in Agency and Responsibility , vol. Vol 4, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
54. Russell Paul,. 2013. “"Responsibility, Naturalism, and the Morality System".” In Shoemaker David, ed., 2013. Oxford Studies in Agency and Responsibility , vol. Vol 1, Oxford: Oxford University Press: 184204.
55. Sartorio Carolina. 2016. Causation and Free Will . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
56. Sears R. 1963. “"Dependency Motivation".” Nebraska Symposium on Motivation , Vol 11: 2564. University of Nebraska Press: Lincoln.
57. Sreenivasan G. 2002. “"Errors about Errors: Virtue Theory and Trait Attribution",” Mind Vol 111:4768.
58. Talbert Matthew. 2012. “"Moral Competence, Moral Blame, and Protest".” Journal of Ethics Vol 16: 89109.
59. Talbert Matthew. 2009. “"Situationism, Normative Competence, and Responsibility for Wartime Behavior".” Journal of Value InquiryVol 43: 41532. [Crossref]
60. Talbert Matthew, and Wolfendale Jessica,. 2015. “"War Crimes: Causes, Excuses, and Blame",” ed. Miller Christian, et al., Character: New Directions from Philosophy, Psychology, and Theology . New York: Oxford University Press.
61. Van Inwagen Peter. 1983. An Essay on Free Will . Oxford: Clarendon Press.
62. Vargas Manuel. 2013a. Building Better Beings . Oxford, uk: Oxford University Press.
63. Vargas Manuel,. 2013b. “"Situationism and Moral Responsibility: Free Will in Fragments",” in Clark Andy,, Kiverstein Julian,, and Vierkant Tillmann (eds.), Decomposing the Will , Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 325349.
64. Watson Gary,. 1987. “"Responsibility and the Limits of Evil: Variations on a Strawsonian Theme".” In Schoeman Ferdinand, ed. 1987. Responsibility, Character, and the Emotions: New Essays in Moral Psychology . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 25686.
65. Wolf Susan. 1990. Freedom within Reason . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
66. Wolf Susan,. 1987. “"Sanity and the Metaphysics of Responsibility".” In Schoeman Ferdinand, ed. 1987. Responsibility, Character, and the Emotions: New Essays in Moral Psychology . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 4662.
67. Zimbardo P. 2007. The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil . Random House Trade Paperbacks.
68. Zimbardo Philip.

Article metrics loading...



Can't access your account?
  • Tools

  • Add to Favorites
  • Printable version
  • Email this page
  • Subscribe to ToC alert
  • Get permissions
  • Recommend to your library

    You must fill out fields marked with: *

    Librarian details
    Your details
    Why are you recommending this title?
    Select reason:
    Journal of Moral Philosophy — Recommend this title to your library
  • Export citations
  • Key

  • Full access
  • Open Access
  • Partial/No accessInformation