Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

I accept this policy

Find out more here

“Victory over Communism: South Korean Protestants’ Ideas about Democracy, Development, and Dictatorship, 1953–1961”

No metrics data to plot.
The attempt to load metrics for this article has failed.
The attempt to plot a graph for these metrics has failed.
The full text of this article is not currently available.

Brill’s MyBook program is exclusively available on BrillOnline Books and Journals. Students and scholars affiliated with an institution that has purchased a Brill E-Book on the BrillOnline platform automatically have access to the MyBook option for the title(s) acquired by the Library. Brill MyBook is a print-on-demand paperback copy which is sold at a favorably uniform low price.

Access this article

+ Tax (if applicable)
Add to Favorites
You must be logged in to use this functionality

image of Journal of American-East Asian Relations

This article complicates the traditional narrative of anti-Communist Christians in Korea, examining the history of anti-communism among them in light of their claims to support democracy and development. Changes in Christian thinking in Korea followed the end of formal fighting in the Korean War. The conflict transformed Korea’s post-colonial history into a developmental struggle, pitting communism versus capitalism in a deadly battle. From the mid-1950s, South Korean Protestants saw the struggle as a competition between two systems, not simply one to eradicate the North Korean regime. From this new perspective, they began condemning political injustice and corruption under President Syngman Rhee. The contradictions in the ideas of Christians were partly embodied in their support for the civil uprising that would topple the Rhee regime, but also in their endorsement of Park Chung-hee’s military takeover in 1961. South Korean Protestants assisted the coup’s central leadership and helped a totalitarian regime come to power. This paradoxical aspect within Korean Protestant history is closely tied to the unique characteristics of its anti-communism and how it evolved after the Korean War.

Affiliations: 1: Sogang University,


Full text loading...


Data & Media loading...

1. Chosŏn Ilbo, 29 September 1961, p. 3.
2. Kidokkongbo [The Christian Weekly], 23 June 1952. p. 2; 4 February 1952, p. 1; 2 March 1959, p. 1; 23 November 1959, p. 1; 2 May 1960, p. 1.
3. “K’ookMinbangonggyemongdandŭngrogŭigŏn” [“About Registration for the National Anti- Communist Enlightenment Group”], 25 October 1960, file BA0136498, “Kungmin pan’gong kyemongdan tŭngnogŭi kŏn” [Records of the National Anti-Communist Enlightenment Club], National Archives of Korea, Government Complex, Daejeon, Republic of Korea.
4. K’ŭrisŭch’an Sinmun [The Christian Press], 10 December 1960, p. 2; 14 January 1961, p. 2.
5. Kyŏnghyang Sinmun, 6 August 1960, p. 3; 21 January 1961, p. 1; 9 February 1961, p. 3; 21 May 1961, p. 1.
6. Tong-A Ilbo, 18 May 1956, p. 1; 21 May 1961, p. 1; 15 May 1962, p. 1.
7. Armstrong Charles K. “"Fraternal Socialism: The International Reconstruction of North Korea, 1953–1962".” Cold War History Vol 5, No. 2 (May 2005): 16187.
8. Cathcart Adam,, and Kraus Charles. “"Peripheral Influence: The Sinŭiju Student Incident of 1945 and the Impact of Soviet Occupation in North Korea".” Journal of Korean Studies Vol 13, No. 1 (Fall 2008): 127.
9. Myŏngsin Ch’ae. Ch’ae Myŏngsin Hoegorok: Sasŏn (Dyoldyuk) Ŭl Nŏmgo Nŏmŏ [Ch’ae Myŏngsin’s Memoirs: Brave Death a Hundred Times]. Seoul: Maeilgyŏngjeshinmunsa, 1994.
10. Tongchin Cho. Chirisanŭro Kan Moksa [The Pastor who Fled to the Chiri Mountains]. Seoul: Byeol, 1994.
11. Yŏngho Ch’oe. "“Rhee Syngman Chŏngbuŭi T’aepyŏngyang Tongmaeng Kusanggwa Asia Minjok Pangongyŏnmang kyŏlsŏng” [“Rhee Syngman Regime’s Ideas of Pacific Alliance and the Asian People Anti-Communist League’s Birth”]", Kukjejŏngch’i nonch’ong [Korean Journal of International Relations]Vol 39, no. 2 (1995): 16582.
12. T’aekpu Chŏn. Han’guk ek’yumenik’ar undongsa [The History of Korean Ecumenical Movement]. Seoul: The National Council of Churches in Korea, 1979.
13. Editorial, "“Han’gugŭn Kyŏngch’algukkain’ga?” [“Is South Korea a Police State?”]". Kidokkyo sasang [Christian Thought]Vol 32 (May 1960): 1011.
14. Editorial. “Yukkun Kunjong 20 nyŏn” [“Twenty Years of Military Chaplaincy”], Saegajŏng [The New Family], Vol 190 (February 1971): 4244.
15. Gülstorff Torben. “"Warming Up a Cooling War: An Introductory Guide on the cias and Other Globally Operating Anti-communist Networks at the Beginning of the Cold War Decade of Détente".” Cold War International History Project Vol 75, Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Washington, dc, 2015.
16. Haga Kai Yin Allison,. “"Rising to the Occasion: The Role of American Missionaries and Korean Pastors in Resisting Communism throughout the Korean War".” In Religion and the Cold War . Philip E Muehlenbeck, Ed., 88112. Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press, 2012.
17. Haga Kai Yin Allison. “An Overlooked Dimension of the Korean War: The Role of Christianity and American Missionaries in the Rise of Korean Nationalism, Anti-Colonialism, and Eventual Civil War, 1884–1953.” Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, College of William and Mary, Williamsburg, va, 2007.
18. Kyŏngjik Han. Han Kyŏngjik Moksa Sŏlgyo Chŏnjip [Complete Sermons of Han Kyŏngjik]. Vol 2 Vols. Seoul: Taehanyesugyo Changnohoe Ch’onghoegyoyukpu, 1971.
19. Hangminsa p’yŏnjipshil [Editorial Board for Anti-Civil Activity]. Sawŏrhyŏngmyŏng Charyojip: 4.19 Minjungsa [Sourcebook of the April Revolution: The Popular History of April 19th]. Seoul: Hangminsa, 1984.
20. Han’guk kidokkyo kyohoe hyŏbŭihoe [Council of Christian Protestant Churches], Kidokkyoyŏn’gam: 1972 [Protestant Yearbook: 1972]. Seoul: Han’guk kidokkyo kyohoe hyŏbŭihoe, 1972.
21. Han’guk kidokkyo kyohoe hyŏbŭihoe 70 nyŏn yŏksa p’yŏnch’an wiwŏnhoe [Seventy Year History Compilation Committee of the Council of Korean Protestant Churches]. Hanadoenŭn Kyohoe Kŭrigo Segye [Becoming One Church and World]. Seoul: Taehan’gidokkyosŏhoe, 1994.
22. Yongp’yo Hong. “"North Korea in the 1950s: The Post Korean War Policies and Their Implications".” Kukjejeongch’I nonch’ong [The Korean Journal of International Relations]Vol 44, No. 5 (2014): 21534.
23. Yŏnghak Hyŏn. "“5.16hyŏngmyŏnggwa Han’gukkyohoeŭi Kwaje” [“Korean Protestantism and the May 16th Revolution”]". Kidokkyo sasang Vol 45 (July 1961): 6265.
24. Ibuk sindo taep’yohoe [North Korean Believers’ Assembly]. Ibuk sindo taep’yohoe munjip [Collected Writings from the North Korean Believers’ Assembly]. Seoul: Ibuk sindo taep’yohoe P’yŏnjib wiwŏnhoe, 1984.
25. Inch’ŏl Kang. Chŏhanggwa T’uhang [Resistance and Surrender]. Osan: Hansindaehakkyo ch’ulp’anbu, 2013.
26. Inch’ŏl Kang. "“Han’guk Kaesin’gyo Pan’gongjuŭiŭi Hyŏngsŏnggwa Chaesaengsan” [“The Formation and Reproduction of Korean Protestant Anti-communism”]". Yŏksabip’yŏng [Critical History]Vol 70 (February 2005): 4063.
27. Inch’ŏl Kang. Han’gukch’ŏnjugyoŭi Yŏksasahoehak [Historical Sociology of Korean Catholicism]. Osan: Hansindaehakkyo ch’ulp’anbu, 2006.
28. Inch’ŏl Kang. Han’gugŭi Kaesin’gyowa Pan’gongjuŭi [Korean Protestantism and Anti- communism]. Seoul: Chungshim, 2006.
29. Inch’ŏl Kang. Han’gukkidokkyohoewa Kukka, Siminsahoe [Korean Protestant Christian Churches and State/Civil society]. Seoul: Han’guk kidokkyo yŏksa yŏn’guso, 1996.
30. Inch’ŏl Kang. "“Wŏllam Kaesin’gyo/Ch’ŏnjugyoŭi Ppuri” [“Roots of the Northern Protestants and Catholics Who Fled South”]". Yŏksabip’yŏng [Critical History]Vol 9 (February 1992): 91141.
31. Wŏnnyŏng Kang. "“Nambukt’ongilgwa Uriŭi Kwaje” [“Korean Unification and Our Task”]". Kidokkyo sasang Vol 40 (February 1961): 4047.
32. Pyŏnghŭi Kim. Han Kyŏngjik Moksa [Pastor Han Kyeong-jik]. Seoul: Kyujangmunhwasa, 1982.
33. Sangt’ae Kim. "“P’yŏngando Kidokkyoseryŏkkwa Ch’inmiellit’ŭŭi Hyŏngsŏng” [“Christian Power in P’yŏngan Province and Formation of the Pro-u.s. Elite”]". Yŏksabip’yŏng Vol 45 (November 1998): 171207.
34. Ŭngho Kim. Han’gukchangnogyo 100nyŏn [100 Years of Korean Presbyterian History]. Seoul: Mongnyangsa, 1984.
35. Hat’ae Kim. "“Munhwajŏk Kŭpchŏn’gie Ch’ŏhan Han’gukkyohoe” [“Korean Church’s Responses to the Cultural Turn”]". Kidokkyo Vol 13 (September 1958): 6067.
36. Hwallan Kim. Kŭ Pitsogŭi Chagŭn Saengmyŏng [A Small Life Inside the Light]. Seoul: Ihwayŏjadaehakkyo ch’ulp’anbu, 1965.
37. Yangsŏn Kim. Han’gukkidokkyohaebang 10nyŏnsa [A Ten Year History of the Liberation of Korean Christianity]. Seoul: Taehan yesugyo ch’onghoe chonggyo kyoyukpu, 1956.
38. Yŏngtal Kim. "“1956, 1957nyŏn Soryŏnŭi P’yŏnghwagongsewa Asia” [“Soviet Peace Offensive in 1956–57 and Asia”]". Sint’aeyang [The New Sun]Vol 78 (April 1959): 196201.
39. Kwon Heonik. The Other Cold War . New York: Columbia University Press, 2010.
40. Cheyŏn Oh. “1960–1971 nyŏn taehak haksaengundong yŏn’gu” [“A Study on University Student Movements in Korean from 1960 to 1971”]. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Seoul National University, Seoul, Republic of Korea, 2014.
41. Ikhŭi Sin et al. "“1956 nyŏndo Kungnaeoe Chŏngserŭl Nonhanda” [“A Discussion on Korea’s Overseas and Domestic Political Situation in 1956”]". Sinsegye [The New World]Vol 1, no. 1 (February 1956): 3856.
42. Chŏngryul Song. “"Han’gugŭi Changnaewa Kidokkyo [Korea’s Future and Christianity]".” Kidokkyo sasang Vol 9 (April 1958): 1315.
43. Szell György,, Pollmann Christoph,, and Tongch’un Kim. “"Introduction".” In Pan’gongŭi Sidae [The Days of Anti-Communism]. Seoul: Tolbegae, 2015.
44. Taehanyesugyo Changnohoe Ch’onghoe Chŏndobu Sanŏpsŏn’gyowiwŏnhoe p’yŏn [Committee for the Industrial Mission of Korean Presbyterian Evangelism, Ed.]. Kyohoewa Toshisanŏpsŏn’gyo [The Churches and Urban Industrial Evangelism]. Seoul: Taehanyesugyo Changnohoe Ch’onghoegyoyukpu, 1981.
45. Unsŏkkinyŏmsaŏphoe. Hanarŭi Mirijukchi Ank’onŭn [A Grain of Wheat Must Die]. Seoul: Catholicch’ulp’ansa, 1967.
46. Haruki Wada. Kitachosen Gendaishi [Contemporary North Korean History]. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten, 2012.
47. Chinch’ŏn . “Han’gukchŏnjaenge Taehan Kyohoeŭi Ipchang [The Church’s Position on the Korean War].” Han’gukch’ŏnjukyohoesaŭi Sŏngch’algwa Chŏnmang [Reflection and Prospects for a History of the Korean Catholic Church]. Vol. ii. Seoul: Catholic Conference of Korea, 2001.
48. yŏn’guso Yŏksahak. Hamkke Ponŭn Han’gukkŭnhyŏndaesa [Korean Modern and Contemporary History]. Seoul: Sŏhaemunjip, 2004.
49. Yŏngnakkyohoe [Yŏngnak Church]. Yŏngnakkyohoe 50nyŏnsa [Fifty-Year History of the Yŏngnak Church]. Seoul: Yŏngnakkyohoe, 1998.
50. Yu Pongyŏng. “"Che3konghwagukkwa Sŭnggong” [“The Third Republic and Sŭnggong Anti-communism]".” Konggun [The Air Force]Vol 81 (December 1963): 100104.
51. Chŏngnan Yun [Jeongran Yoon]. "“1950nyŏndae ‘kidokkyosasang’ ŭi ch’anggangwa kŭ panghyang” [“Founding and Direction of the Christian Thought in 1950s”]". Yŏksahak yŏn’gu [The Korean Journal of History], Vol 48 (November 2012): 20245.
52. Chŏngnan Yun [Jeongran Yoon]. Hangukchŏnjaenggwa Kidokgyo [The Korean War and Protestantism]. Seoul: Hanulak’ademi, 2015.
53. Chŏngnan Yun [Jeongran Yoon]. "“Han’guk chŏnjaeng kuhomuljawa sŏbukch’ulsin wŏllamgidokgyoindŭlŭi seryŏkhwa” [“Korean War Relief and Empowerment of the Northwestern Christians”]". Sungshilsahak [The Historical Review of Soong Sil University]Vol 34 (June 2015): 261306.
54. Chŏngnan Yun [Jeongran Yoon]. "“Sŏbukch’ŏngnyŏnhoe ch’ulsindŭlŭi chŏngch’ijŏk paejewa puhwal” [“Political Exclusion and Resurrection of the Northwest Youth Association”]". Sungshilsahak Vol 33 (December 2014): 15798.

Article metrics loading...



Can't access your account?
  • Tools

  • Add to Favorites
  • Printable version
  • Email this page
  • Subscribe to ToC alert
  • Get permissions
  • Recommend to your library

    You must fill out fields marked with: *

    Librarian details
    Your details
    Why are you recommending this title?
    Select reason:
    Journal of American-East Asian Relations — Recommend this title to your library
  • Export citations
  • Key

  • Full access
  • Open Access
  • Partial/No accessInformation