Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

I accept this policy

Find out more here

Students as Consumers: Commodifying or Democratising Learning?

No metrics data to plot.
The attempt to load metrics for this article has failed.
The attempt to plot a graph for these metrics has failed.
The full text of this article is not currently available.

Brill’s MyBook program is exclusively available on BrillOnline Books and Journals. Students and scholars affiliated with an institution that has purchased a Brill E-Book on the BrillOnline platform automatically have access to the MyBook option for the title(s) acquired by the Library. Brill MyBook is a print-on-demand paperback copy which is sold at a favorably uniform low price.

Access this article

+ Tax (if applicable)
Add to Favorites
You must be logged in to use this functionality

image of International Journal of Chinese Education

AbstractThe positioning of students as ‘consumers’ of education is becoming a global phenomenon. This paper begins by drawing on insights from both the marketing and education literatures to assess the impact of this development on the processes and outcomes of education, on the professional practices of faculty and on widening participation. Pierre Bourdieu’s conceptual framework is then applied to analyse how consumer mechanisms are mediated by the organisational cultures and practices within universities. These theoretical insights are combined with data from different national contexts to identify both positive and negative aspects of this trend. The paper goes on to consider the critique of consumerism as something that promotes commodification and passive learning. Some other ways of empowering students more actively in their learning, including ‘student voice’ and ‘co-production’ initiatives that are currently fashionable in Western policy contexts, are then discussed. While these are seen by some commentators as examples of ‘pre-figurative democratic practice’, others have identified them as having the potential to alienate students through tokenistic provision or as serving a neo-liberal policy agenda through the ‘responsibilisation’ of students. The paper concludes by suggesting that such initiatives may have the potential to challenge academic complacency without undermining core academic values.

Affiliations: 1: School of Management, University of BathUK


Full text loading...


Data & Media loading...

1. Arnould E.J. , Thompson C.J. "“Consumer Culture Theory (CCT): Twenty Years of Research.”" Journal of Consumer Research 2005 Vol 31 868 882 [Crossref]
2. Ball S.J. "“Performativity, Commodification and Community: An I-spy guide to the neoliberal university.”" British Journal of Educational Studies 2012 Vol 60 no. 1 17 28 [Crossref]
3. Bernstein B. Pedagogy, Symbolic Control and Identity 1996 London Taylor and Francis
4. Biggs J. "“Enhancing Teaching through Constructive Alignment.”" Higher Education 1996 Vol 32 no. 2 347 364 [Crossref]
5. BIS Higher ambitions: the future of universities in a knowledge economy 2009 London Department for Business, Innovation and Skills
6. BIS Higher Education: students at the heart of the system 2011 London Department for Business, Innovation and Skills
7. Blackstone T. Students are now ‘critical consumers’ 1999 London DFEE Press
8. Bourdieu P. Richardson G.R. "“The forms of capital.”" Handbook of theory and research for the sociology of education 1986 New York Greenwood Press,
9. Bourdieu P. Homo academicus 1988 Cambridge Polity Press,
10. Bourdieu P. The state nobility 1996 Cambridge Polity Press
11. Brittain K. "“What is the Student Experience?”" Wonkhe
12. Brown P. , Green A. , Lauder H. High skills: Globalisation, competitiveness, and skill 2001 Oxford Oxford University Press
13. Brown R. "“Risk-Based Quality Assusrance: the risks.”" New Arrangements for Quality Assurance in Higher Education 2013 Oxford HEPI edited by Higher Education Policy Institute
14. Browne J. , Barber M. , Coyle D. , Eastwood D. , King J. , Nayak R. , Sands P. Securing a sustainable future for higher education: an independent review of higher education funding and student finance 2010 London Department of Business, Innovation and Skills
15. Castells M. Muller J. , Cloete N. , Badat S. "“Information technology and global development.”" Challenges of globalisation: South African debates with Manuel Castells 2001 Cape Town Maskew Miller/ Longman
16. Cheney G. , McMillan J. , Schwartzman R. "“Should we buy the ‘student-as- consumer’ metaphor?”" The Montana Professor 1997 Vol 7 no. 3
17. Crook C. Steeples C. , Jones C. "“The campus experience of networked learning.”" Networked learning: Perspectives and issues 2002 Dordrecht Springer
18. Currie J. , Vidovich L. "“Privatization and competition policies for Australian universities.”" International Journal of Educational Development 2000 Vol 20 no. 2 135 151 [Crossref]
19. Deem R. "“Globalisation, new managerialism, academic capitalism and entrepreneuralism in universities: is the local dimension still important?”" Comparative Education 2001 Vol 37 no. 1 7 20 [Crossref]
20. Demos "“Pupil power.”" Demos
21. Department for Education and Employment (DfEE) Higher education for the 21st century: Response to the Dearing report 1998 London HMSO
22. Department for Education and Skills (DfES) The future of higher education 2003 London HMSO
23. Diamond A. , Vorley T. , Roberts J. , Jones S. Behavioural Approaches to Understanding Student Choice 2012 York Higher Education Academy
24. Dickinson J. "“A glass of Sangria, my cake and some time to eat it please.”" Wonkhe
25. Dill D.D. "“Higher education markets and public policy.”" Higher Education Policy 1997 Vol 10 167 185 [Crossref]
26. Drummond G. Consumer confusion reduction strategies in education 2004 Buckingham Open University Press
27. Enders J. , Jongbloed B. Public-private dynamics in higher education, expectations, developments, and outcomes 2007 Bielefeld Transcript
28. Entwistle N.J. Brown S. , Armstrong S. , Thompson G. "“Motivating and Approaches to Learning: Motivating and Conceptions of Teaching.”" Motivating Students 1998 London Kogan Page
29. Ferenstein G. "“How California’s Online Education Pilot Will End College As We Know It.”" TechCrunch
30. Foley B. , Goldstein H. Measuring Success: League tables in the public sector 2012 London British Academy
31. Ford J.B. , Joseph M. , Joseph B. "“Importance-performance analysis as a strategic tool for service marketers: The case of service quality perceptions of business students in New Zealand and the USA.”" Journal of Services Marketing 1999 Vol 13 no. 2 171 186 [Crossref]
32. Gilbert C. 2020 Vision: report of the teaching and learning in 2020 review group 2006
33. Grisoni L. , Wilkinson J. "“Undergraduate business and management students as consumers of identity.”" 2005 Paper No. 3.20 presented at SRHE Annual Conference 2005 December Edinburgh 13 15
34. Grönroos C. "“Adopting a service logic for marketing.”" Marketing Theory 2006 Vol 6 no. 3 317 334 [Crossref]
35. Gustafsson U. , Driver S. "“Parents power and public participation: Sure Start, an experiment in New Labour governance.”" Social Policy and Administration 2005 Vol 39 no. 5 528 543 [Crossref]
36. Haig B. "“Scientific problems and the conduct of research.”" Educational Philosophy and Theory 1987 Vol 19 no. 2 22 32 [Crossref]
37. Hall M. Muller J, , Cloete N. , Badat N. , Badat S. "“Education and the Margins of the Network Society.”" South African Debates with Castells 2001 Cape Town Maskew Miller Longman
38. Halsey A.H. , Trow M.A. The British academics 1971 Boston Harvard University Press [Crossref]
39. Hargreaves D. Personalising learning—2: student voice and assessment for learning 2004 London Specialist Schools Trust
40. Henkell M. Academic identities and policy change in higher education 2000 London Jessica Kingsley Publishers
41. Hirsch F. Social limits to growth 1977 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press
42. James R. , Baldwin G. , McInnis C. "“Which university? The factors influencing the choices of prospective undergraduates. Evaluations and Investigations Program, Higher Education Division (Canberra, DEST).”" DEST
43. Kelly P. "“Youth at risk: processes of individualisation and responsibilisation in the risk society.”" Discourse 2001 Vol 22 no. 1 23 33
44. King R. , Locke W. , Puncher M. , Richardson J. , Verbik L. Counting what is measured or measuring what counts? League tables and their impact on higher education institutions in England 2008 Report to HEFCE by the Centre for Higher Education Research and Information (CHERI), Open University, and Hobsons Research
45. Kotler P. Strategic marketing for educational institutions 1995 Englewood Cliffs, NJ Prentice-Hall
46. Lagace M. "“Your customers: Use them or lose them.”" Harvard Business School Working Knowledge Series
47. Lakoff G. , Johnson M. Philosophy in the flesh: the embodied mind and its challenge to Western thought 1999 New York Basic
48. Lambert C. , Parker A. , Neary M. "“Teaching entrepreneurialism and critical pedagogy: Reinventing the higher education curriculum.”" Teaching in Higher Education 2007 Vol 12 525 536 [Crossref]
49. Leadbeater C. Personalization: how can we put the learner at the heart of the education system? 2004 London DfES
50. Leadbeater C. The shape of things to come: personalized learning through collaboration 2005 London DfES
51. Lemke T. "“The birth of bio-politics: Michael Foucault’s lectures at the College de France on neo-liberal governmentality.”" Economy and Society 2001 Vol 30 no. 2 190 207 [Crossref]
52. Linehan P. St John’s College Cambridge a History 2011 Woodbridge The Boydell Press
53. Little B. , Locke W. , Scesa A. , Williams R. Report to HEFCE on Student Engagement 2009 Milton Keynes Centre for Higher Education Research and Information
54. Lowrie A. , Willmott H. "“Accreditation sickness in the consumption of business education: the vacuum in AACSB standard setting.”" Management Learning 2009 Vol 40 no. 4 411 420 [Crossref]
55. Lusch R.F. , Vargo S.L. The service-dominant logic of marketing: Dialog, debate, and directions 2006 Marmonk, NY ME Sharpe
56. Marginson S. "“Dynamics of national and global competition in higher education.”" Higher Education 2006 Vol 52 1 39 [Crossref]
57. Marton F. , Saljo R. Marton F, , Hounsell D. , Entwistle N. "“Approaches to Learning.”" The Experience of Learning 1984 Edinburgh Scottish Academic Press
58. McClaran A. "“Developing the New Higher Education Review.”" New Arrangements for Quality Assurance in Higher Education 2013 Oxford HEPI edited by Higher Education Policy Institute
59. McCulloch A. "“The student as co-producer: learning from public administration about the student-university relationship.”" Studies in Higher Education 2009 Vol 34 171 183 [Crossref]
60. McGettigan A. "“Q. Will ‘Moocs’ be the scourge or saviour or higher education?”" The Guardian 2013 May 12
61. Mendleson N. , Polonsky M.J. "“Using strategicalliances to develop credible green vegetables in Scotland.”" Journal of Consumer Marketing 1995 Vol 12 no. 2 18 24 [Crossref]
62. Mezirow J. Transformative dimensions of adult learning 1991 San Francisco Jossey-Bass
63. Middleton C. "“Models of state and market in the modernisation of higher education.”" British Journal of Sociology of Education 2000 Vol 21 no. 4 537 554 [Crossref]
64. Moja T. , Cloete N. "“Higher Education: Vanishing Borders and New Boundaries in the Information Society.”" Challenges of Globalisation—South African Debates with Manuel Castells 2001 Cape Town Maskew Miller Longman
65. Moogan Y. , Baron S. , Harris K. "“Decision-Making Behaviour of Potential Higher Education Students.”" Higher Education Quarterly 1999 Vol 53 no. 3 211 228 [Crossref]
66. Moore R. , Muller J. "“The discourse of ‘voice’ and the problem of knowledge and identity in the sociology of education.”" British Journal of Sociology of Education 1999 Vol 20 no. 2 189 206 [Crossref]
67. Morley L. Theorising Quality in Higher Education 2004 London IOE Press
68. Naidoo R. "“The ‘Third Way’ to widening participation and maintaining quality in higher education: lessons from the United Kingdom.”" Journal of Educational Enquiry 2000 Vol 1 no. 2 24 38
69. Naidoo R. "“Fields and institutional strategy: Bourdieu on the relationship between higher education, inequality and society.”" British Journal of Sociology of Education 2004 Vol 25 no. 4 457 471 [Crossref]
70. Naidoo R. "“The competitive state and the mobilised market: higher education policy reform in the United Kingdom (1980-2007).”" Critique Internationale 2008 April/June Vol 39 47 65 [Crossref]
71. Naidoo R. , Jamieson I. Ninnes P , Hellsten M. "“Knowledge in the Marketplace: The global commodification of teaching and learning in higher education.”" Higher Education: Critical explorations of pedagogy and policy 2005 Dordrecht Springer
72. Naidoo R. , Shankar A. , Veer E. "“The consumerist turn in higher education: Policy aspirations and outcomes.”" Journal of Marketing Management 2011 Vol 27 no. 11-12 1142 1162 [Crossref]
73. Ng I.C.L. , Forbes J. "“Education as Service: The understanding of university experience through the service logic.”" Journal of Marketing for Higher Education 2009 Vol 19 38 64 [Crossref]
74. Nixon E. , Scullion R. , Molesworth M. Molesworth M. , Scullion R. , Nixon E. "“How choice in higher education can create conservative learners.”" The marketisation of higher education and the student as consumer 2010 London Routledge 196 208 Nixon
75. Noble D.F. Robins K. , Webster F, "“Rehearsal for Revolution.”" The Virtual University Gazette 2002 Oxford Oxford University Press
76. Parr C. "“Will Moocs fail to give students help they need?”" Times Higher Education 2013 February 14
77. Powell W.W. , DiMaggio P.G. The new institutionalism in organisational analysis 1991 New Jersey Princeton Press
78. Prahalad C.K. , Ramaswamy V. "“The co-creation connection.”" Strategy and Business 2002 Vol 27 no. 2 51 60
79. Prahalad C.K. , Ramaswamy V. The future of competition: Co-creating unique value with customers 2004 Boston Harvard Business School
80. Pugsy L. "“Throwing your brains at it: higher education, markets and choice.”" International Studies in Sociology of Education 1998 Vol 8 no. 1 71 92 [Crossref]
81. Quality Assurance Agency Code of Practice for the assurance of quality and standards in higher education: section 5 Academic appeals and student complaints on academic matters 2000 Gloucester Quality Assurance Agency
82. Reay D. , Davies J. , David M. , Ball S.J. "“Choices of degree or degrees of choice? Class, ‘race’ and the higher education choice process.”" Sociology 2001 Vol 35 no. 4 855 874
83. Robertson S.L. "“The EU, ‘regulatory state regionalism’ and new modes of higher education governance.”" University of Bristol
84. Rudduck J. "“The innovation bazaar: determining priorities, building coherence—the case of student voice.”" 2004 Keynote address presented at the UCET Annual Conference November Hinckley
85. Sabri D. "“What’s wrong with ‘the student experience’?”" Discourse 2011 Vol 32 no. 5 657 667
86. Seltzer K. , Bentley T. The creative age: knowledge and skills for the new economy 1999 London Demos
87. Shankar A. , Cherrier H. , Canniford R. "“Consumer empowerment: A Foucauldian interpretation.”" European Journal of Marketing 2006 Vol 40 1013 1030 [Crossref]
88. Shulman L. "“Knowledge and Teaching: Foundations of the New Reform.”" Harvard Educational Review 1987 Vol 57 1 22 [Crossref]
89. Shumar W. College for sale: A critique of the commodification of higher education 1997 London Falmer Press
90. Slaughter S. , Leslie L. Academic capitalism: Politics, policies, and the entrepreneurial university 1997 Baltimore, MD Johns Hopkins University Press
91. Starr D. " China and the Confucian Educational Model " Teaching and Learning Position Paper 2012 Durham Universitas 21
92. Thrift N.J. Knowing capitalism 2005 London Sage
93. Tomusk V. "“Reproduction of the ‘state nobility’ in Eastern Europe: past patterns and new practices.”" British Journal of Sociology of Education 2000 Vol 21 no. 2 269 282 [Crossref]
94. Trow M. " From Mass Higher Education to Universal Access: The American Advantage " Research and Occasional Paper Series 2000 Berkeley University of Californi
95. Vargo S.L. , Lusch R.F. "“Evolving to a new dominant logic for marketing.”" Journal of Marketing 2004 Vol 68 1 17 [Crossref]
96. Whitty G. , Power S. , Halpin D. Devolution and Choice in Education: the school, the state and the market 1998 Buckingham Open University Press
97. Whitty G. , Wisby E. "“Whose voice? An exploration of the current policy interest in pupil involvement in school decision-making.”" International Studies in Sociology of Education 2007 Vol 17 no. 3 303 319 [Crossref]
98. Willetts D. "“Higher education and the student experience.”"
99. Williams G. Subject benchmarking in the United Kingdom, Research Paper for Public Policy for Academic Quality 2005 Chapel Hill University of North Carolina
100. Williams J. Consuming Higher Education: Why learning can’t be bought 2012 London Bloomsbury
101. Wisby E. "“Subject benchmarking as a ‘new mode’ of regulating teaching in higher education and its implications for academic autonomy—including a case study of the Sociology Benchmarking Group.”" 2002 PhD diss.
102. Young M. "“Rescuing the sociology of educational knowledge from the extremes of voice discourse: towards a new theoretical basis for the sociology of the curriculum.”" British Journal of Sociology of Education 2000 Vol 21 no. 4 523 536 [Crossref]
103. Young M. Bringing knowledge back in: From social constructivism to social realism in the sociology of education 2008 London Routledge
104. Young M. , Muller J. "“Disciplines, skills and the university.”" Higher Education 2013 Vol 66 no. 1 (In press)

Article metrics loading...



Can't access your account?
  • Tools

  • Add to Favorites
  • Printable version
  • Email this page
  • Subscribe to ToC alert
  • Get permissions
  • Recommend to your library

    You must fill out fields marked with: *

    Librarian details
    Your details
    Why are you recommending this title?
    Select reason:
    International Journal of Chinese Education — Recommend this title to your library
  • Export citations
  • Key

  • Full access
  • Open Access
  • Partial/No accessInformation