Cookies Policy
X

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

I accept this policy

Find out more here

Muscle Vibration-Induced Illusions: Review of Contributing Factors, Taxonomy of Illusions and User’s Guide

No metrics data to plot.
The attempt to load metrics for this article has failed.
The attempt to plot a graph for these metrics has failed.
The full text of this article is not currently available.

Brill’s MyBook program is exclusively available on BrillOnline Books and Journals. Students and scholars affiliated with an institution that has purchased a Brill E-Book on the BrillOnline platform automatically have access to the MyBook option for the title(s) acquired by the Library. Brill MyBook is a print-on-demand paperback copy which is sold at a favorably uniform low price.

Access this article

+ Tax (if applicable)
Add to Favorites
You must be logged in to use this functionality

image of Multisensory Research
For more content, see Seeing and Perceiving and Spatial Vision.

Limb muscle vibration creates an illusory limb movement in the direction corresponding to lengthening of the vibrated muscle. Neck muscle vibration results in illusory motion of visual and auditory stimuli. Attributed to the activation of muscle spindles, these and related effects are of great interest as a tool in research on proprioception, for rehabilitation of sensorimotor function and for multisensory immersive virtual environments. However, these illusions are not easy to elicit in a consistent manner. We review factors that influence them, propose their classification in a scheme that links this area of research to perception theory, and provide practical suggestions to researchers. Local factors that determine the illusory effect of vibration include properties of the vibration stimulus such as its frequency, amplitude and duration, and properties of the vibrated muscle, such as contraction and fatigue. Contextual (gestalt) factors concern the relationship of the vibrated body part to the rest of the body and the environment. Tactile and visual cues play an important role, and so does movement, imagined or real. The best-known vibration illusions concern one’s own body and can be classified as ‘first-order’ due to a direct link between activity in muscle spindles and the percept. More complex illusions involve other sensory modalities and external objects, and provide important clues regarding the hidden role of proprioception, our ‘silent’ sense. Our taxonomy makes explicit this and other distinctions between different illusory effects. We include User’s Guide with tips for anyone wishing to conduct a vibration study.

Affiliations: 1: 1Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Sydney, 75 East St, Lidcombe 2141 NSW, Sydney, Australia ; 2: 2Neuroscience Research Australia, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia

*To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: tatjana.seizova-cajic@sydney.edu.au
Loading

Full text loading...

/content/journals/10.1163/22134808-00002544
Loading

Data & Media loading...

1. Albert F., Bergenheim M., Ribot-Ciscar E., Roll J.-P. (2006). "The Ia afferent feedback of a given movement evokes the illusion of the same movement when returned to the subject via muscle tendon vibration", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 172, 163174. [Crossref]
2. Ansems G. E., Allen T. J., Proske U. (2006). "Position sense at the human forearm in the horizontal plane during loading and vibration of elbow muscles", J. Physiol. Vol 576, 445455. [Crossref]
3. Bergenheim M., Ribot-Ciscar E., Roll J.-P. (2000). "Proprioceptive population coding of two-dimensional limb movements in humans: I. Muscle spindle feedback during spatially oriented movements", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 134, 301310. [Crossref]
4. Biguer B., Donaldson I. M. L., Hein A., Jeannerod M. (1988). "Neck muscle vibration modifies the representation of visual-motion and direction in man", Brain Vol 111, 14051424. [Crossref]
5. Blanchard C., Roll R., Roll J.-P., Kavounoudias A. (2013). "Differential contributions of vision, touch and muscle proprioception to the coding of hand movements", PLoS One Vol 8, e62475. [Crossref]
6. Bock O., Pipereit K., Mierau A. (2007). "A method to reversibly degrade proprioceptive feedback in research on human motor control", J. Neurosci. Meth. Vol 160, 246250. [Crossref]
7. Brown M. M., Engberg I., Matthews P. B. (1967). "The relative sensitivity to vibration of muscle receptors of the cat", J. Physiol. Vol 192, 773800. [Crossref]
8. Brun C., Guerraz M. (2015). "Anchoring the ‘floating arm’: use of proprioceptive and mirror visual feedback from one arm to control involuntary displacement of the other arm", Neuroscience Vol 310, 268278. [Crossref]
9. Burke D., Hagbarth K. E., Lofstedt L., Wallin B. G. (1976a). "The responses of human muscle spindle endings to vibration of non-contracting muscles", J. Physiol. Vol 261, 673693. [Crossref]
10. Burke D., Hagbarth K. E., Lofstedt L., Wallin B. G. (1976b). "The responses of human muscle spindle endings to vibration during isometric contraction", J. Physiol. Vol 261, 695711. [Crossref]
11. Calvin-Figuière S., Romaiguère P., Gilhodes J.-C., Roll J.-P. (1999). "Antagonist motor responses correlate with kinesthetic illusions induced by tendon vibration", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 124, 342350. [Crossref]
12. Calvin-Figuière S., Romaiguère P., Roll J.-P. (2000). "Relations between the directions of vibration-induced kinesthetic illusions and the pattern of activation of antagonist muscles", Brain Res. Vol 881, 128138. [Crossref]
13. Clark F. J., Matthews P. B., Muir R. B. (1979). "Effect of the amplitude of muscle vibration on the subjectively experienced illusion of movement [proceedings]", J. Physiol. Vol 296, 14P15P.
14. Conrad M. O., Scheidt R. A., Schmit B. D. (2011). "Effects of wrist tendon vibration on arm tracking in people poststroke", J. Neurophysiol. Vol 106, 14801488. [Crossref]
15. Cordo P., Gandevia S. C., Hales J. P., Burke D., Laird G. (1993). "Force and displacement-controlled tendon vibration in humans", Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. Vol 89, 4553. [Crossref]
16. Cordo P. J., Gurfinkel V. S., Brumagne S., Flores-Vieira C. (2005). "Effect of slow, small movement on the vibration-evoked kinesthetic illusion", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 167, 324334. [Crossref]
17. Cordo P., Lutsep H., Cordo L., Wright W. G., Cacciatore T., Skoss R. (2009). "Assisted movement with enhanced sensation (AMES): coupling motor and sensory to remediate motor deficits in chronic stroke patients", Neurorehabil. Neural Repair Vol 23, 6777. [Crossref]
18. Craske B. (1977). "Perception of impossible limb positions induced by tendon vibration", Science Vol 196, 7173. [Crossref]
19. DiZio P., Lackner J. R., Champney R. K. (2014). "Proprioceptive adaptation and aftereffects", in: Handbook of Virtual Environments: Design, Implementation, and Applications, Hale K. S., Stanney K. M. (Eds), pp.  835856. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA.
20. Ehrsson H. H., Kito T., Sadato N., Passingham R. E., Naito E. (2005). "Neural substrate of body size: illusory feeling of shrinking of the waist", PLoS Biol. Vol 3, 18. [Crossref]
21. Frima N., Rome S. M., Grünewald R. A. (2003). "The effect of fatigue on abnormal vibration induced illusion of movement in idiopathic focal dystonia", J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiat. Vol 74, 11541156. [Crossref]
22. Fuentes C. T., Gomi H., Haggard P. (2012). "Temporal features of human tendon vibration illusions", Eur. J. Neurosci. Vol 36, 37093717. [Crossref]
23. Gallagher S. (2005). "The terms of embodiment", in: How the Body Shapes the Mind, Gallagher S. (Ed.), pp.  1739. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK. [Crossref]
24. Gandevia S. C. (1996). "Kinesthesia: roles for afferent signals and motor commands", in: Handbook of Physiology, Sect. 12, Exercise: Regulation and Integration of Multiple Systems, Shepherd J. T., Rowell L. B. (Eds), pp.  128172. Oxford University Press, New York, NY, USA.
25. Gay A., Parratte S., Salazard B., Guinard D., Pham T., Legre R., Roll J. P. (2007). "Proprioceptive feedback enhancement induced by vibratory stimulation in complex regional pain syndrome type I: an open comparative pilot study in 11 patients", Joint Bone Spine Vol 74, 461466. [Crossref]
26. Gilhodes J. C., Roll J. P., Tardy-Gervet M. F. (1986). "Perceptual and motor effects of agonist-antagonist muscle vibration in man", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 61, 395402. [Crossref]
27. Goodwin G. M., McCloskey D. I., Matthews P. B. (1972a). "The contribution of muscle afferents to kinaesthesia shown by vibration induced illusions of movement and by the effects of paralysing joint afferents", Brain Vol 95, 705748. [Crossref]
28. Goodwin G. M., McCloskey D. I., Matthews B. C. M. (1972b). "Proprioceptive illusions induced by muscle vibration: contribution by muscle spindles to perception?" Science Vol 175, 13821384. [Crossref]
29. Gooey K., Bradfield O., Talbot J., Morgan D. L., Proske U. (2000). "Effects of body orientation, load and vibration on sensing position and movement at the human elbow joint", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 133, 340348. [Crossref]
30. Graybiel A., Hupp D. I. (1946). "The oculogyral illusion, a form of apparent motion which may be observed following stimulation of the semicircular canals", J. Aviat. Med. Vol 43, 327.
31. Gregory J. E., Morgan D. L., Proske U. (1988). "Responses of muscle spindles depend on their history of activation and movement", Prog. Brain Res. Vol 74, 8590. [Crossref]
32. Gregory J. E., Morgan D. L., Proske U. (2004). "Responses of muscle spindles following a series of eccentric contractions", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 157, 234240. [Crossref]
33. Hagbarth K., Eklund G. (1966). "Motor effects of vibratory muscle stimuli in man", in: Nobel Symposium I, Muscular Afferents and Motor Control, Granit R. (Ed.), pp.  177186. Almqvist and Wiksell, Stockholm, Sweden.
34. Hagura N., Takei T., Hirose S., Aramaki Y., Matsumura M., Sadato N., Naito E. (2007). "Activity in the posterior parietal cortex mediates visual dominance over kinesthesia", J. Neurosci. Vol 27, 70477053. [Crossref]
35. Holcombe A. O., Seizova-Cajic T. (2008). "Illusory motion reversals from unambiguous motion with visual, proprioceptive, and tactile stimuli", Vision Res. Vol 48, 17431757. [Crossref]
36. Howard I. P. (1997). "Interactions within and between the spatial senses", J. Vestib. Res. Vol 7, 311346. [Crossref]
37. Inglis J. T., Frank J. S. (1990). "The effect of agonist/antagonist muscle vibration on human position sense", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 81, 573580. [Crossref]
38. Inglis J. T., Frank J. S., Inglis B. (1991). "The effect of muscle vibration on human position sense during movements controlled by lengthening muscle contraction", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 84, 631634. [Crossref]
39. Izumizaki M., Tsuge M., Akai L., Proske U., Homma I. (2010). "The illusion of changed position and movement from vibrating one arm is altered by vision or movement of the other arm", J. Physiol. Vol 588, 27892800. [Crossref]
40. Jones L. A. (1988). "Motor illusions: what do they reveal about proprioception?" Psychol. Bull. Vol 103, 7286. [Crossref]
41. Kito T., Hashimoto T., Yoneda T., Katamoto S., Naito E. (2006). "Sensory processing during kinesthetic aftereffect following illusory hand movement elicited by tendon vibration", Brain Res. Vol 1114, 7584. [Crossref]
42. Lackner J. R. (1988). "Some proprioceptive influences on the perceptual representation of body shape and orientation", Brain Vol 111 (Pt 2), 281297. [Crossref]
43. Lackner J. R., Levine M. S. (1979). "Changes in apparent body orientation and sensory localization induced by vibration of postural muscles: vibratory myesthetic illusions", Aviat. Space Environ. Med. Vol 50, 346354.
44. Lackner J. R., Taublieb A. B. (1984). "Influence of vision on vibration-induced illusions of limb movement", Exp. Neurol. Vol 85, 97106. [Crossref]
45. Leonardis D., Frisoli A., Barsotti M., Carrozzino M., Bergamasco M. (2014). "Multisensory feedback can enhance embodiment within an enriched virtual walking scenario", Presence Camb. Vol 23, 253266. [Crossref]
46. Lewald J., Karnath H. O., Ehrenstein W. H. (1999). "Neck-proprioceptive influence on auditory lateralization", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 125, 389396. [Crossref]
47. Lindauer M. S., Baust R. F. (1974). "Comparisons between 25 reversible and ambiguous figures on measures of latency, duration, and fluctuation", Behav. Res. Methods Instrum. Comput. Vol 6, 19. [Crossref]
48. Longo M. R., Kammers M. P., Gomi H., Tsakiris M., Haggard P. (2009). "Contraction of body representation induced by proprioceptive conflict", Curr. Biol. Vol 19, 727728. [Crossref]
49. Manning H. L., Basner R., Ringler J., Rand C., Fencl V., Weinberger S. E., Weiss J. W., Schwartzstein R. M. (1991). "Effect of chest wall vibration on breathlessness in normal subjects", J. Appl. Physiol. Vol 71, 175181.
50. Matthews P. B. (1966). "The reflex excitation of the soleus muscle of the decerebrate cat caused by vibration applied to its tendon", J. Physiol. Vol 184, 450472. [Crossref]
51. Matthews P. B. (1988). "Proprioceptors and their contribution to somatosensory mapping: complex messages require complex processing", Can. J. Physiol. Pharmacol. Vol 66, 430438. [Crossref]
52. McCloskey D. I. (1973). "Differences between the senses of movement and position shown by the effects of loading and vibration of muscles in man", Brain Res. Vol 61, 119131. [Crossref]
53. McCloskey D. I. (1978). "Kinesthetic sensibility", Physiol. Rev. Vol 58, 763820.
54. McCloskey D. I. (1981). "Corollary discharges: motor commands and perception", in: Handbook of Physiology, Vol. 2, The Nervous System, Motor Control, Brooks V. B. (Ed.), pp.  14151447. American Physiological Society, Bethesda, MD, USA.
55. Naito E. (2004). "Sensing limb movements in the motor cortex: how humans sense limb movement", Neuroscientist Vol 10, 7382. [Crossref]
56. Naito E., Ehrsson H. H. (2001). "Kinesthetic illusion of wrist movement activates motor-related areas", Neuroreport Vol 12, 38053809. [Crossref]
57. Naito E., Ehrsson H. H., Geyer S., Zilles K., Roland P. E. (1999). "Illusory arm movements activate cortical motor areas: a positron emission tomography study", J. Neurosci. Vol 19, 61346144.
58. Naito E., Roland P. E., Ehrsson H. H. (2002). "I feel my hand moving: a new role of the primary motor cortex in somatic perception of limb movement", Neuron Vol 36, 979988. [Crossref]
59. Naito E., Roland P. E., Grefkes C., Choi H. J., Eickhoff S., Geyer S., Zilles K., Ehrsson H. H. (2005). "Dominance of the right hemisphere and role of area 2 in human kinesthesia", J. Neurophysiol. Vol 93, 10201034. [Crossref]
60. Porro C. A., Francescato M. P., Cettolo V., Diamond M. E., Baraldi P., Zuiani C., Bazzocchi M., Di Prampero P. E. (1996). "Primary motor and sensory cortex activation during motor performance and motor imagery: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study", J. Neurosci. Vol 16, 76887698.
61. Precision Microdrives Ltd. (2016). AB-004: Understanding ERM Vibration Motor Characteristics [Online]. Available: https://www.precisionmicrodrives.com/application-notes/ab-004-understanding-erm-vibration-motor-characteristics. Accessed June 28, 2016.
62. Precision Microdrives Ltd. (2016). AB-029: Vibration Motors — Voltage vs Frequency vs Amplitude [Online]. Available: . Accessed June 28, 2016.
63. Precision Microdrives Ltd. (2016). VAB-02: How Do Vibration Motors Work? [Online]. Available: . Accessed June 28, 2016.
64. Proske U., Gandevia S. C. (2012). "The proprioceptive senses: their roles in signaling body shape, body position and movement, and muscle force", Physiol. Rev. Vol 92, 16511697. [Crossref]
65. Proske U., Morgan D. L., Gregory J. E. (1993). "Thixotropy in skeletal muscle and in muscle spindles: a review", Prog. Neurobiol. Vol 41, 705721. [Crossref]
66. Proske U., Tsay A., Allen T. (2014). "Muscle thixotropy as a tool in the study of proprioception", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 232, 33973412. [Crossref]
67. Rabin E., Gordon A. M. (2004). "Influence of fingertip contact on illusory arm movements", J. Appl. Physiol. Vol 96, 15551560. [Crossref]
68. Rabin E., Gordon A. M. (2006). "Prior experience and current goals affect muscle-spindle and tactile integration", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 169, 407416. [Crossref]
69. Ramachandran V. S., Altschuler E. L. (2009). "The use of visual feedback, in particular mirror visual feedback, in restoring brain function", Brain Vol 132, 16931710. [Crossref]
70. Redon C., Hay L., Rigal R., Roll J. P. (1994). "Contribution of the propriomuscular channel to movement coding in children: a study involving the use of vibration-induced kinaesthetic illusion", Hum. Mov. Sci. Vol 13, 95108. [Crossref]
71. Regueme S. C., Barthèlemy J., Gauthier G. M., Nicol C. (2007). "Changes in illusory ankle movements induced by tendon vibrations during the delayed recovery phase of stretch-shortening cycle fatigue: an indirect study of muscle spindle sensitivity modifications", Brain Res. Vol 1185, 129135. [Crossref]
72. Rinderknecht M. D. (2012). "Device for a novel hand and wrist rehabilitation strategy for stroke patients based on illusory movements induced by tendon vibration", in: 16th IEEE Mediterranean Electrotechnical Conference (MELECON), Medina, Tunisia, pp.  926931. DOI:.
73. Roll J. P., Vedel J. P. (1982). "Kinaesthetic role of muscle afferents in man, studied by tendon vibration and microneurography", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 47, 177190. [Crossref]
74. Roll J. P., Vedel J. P., Ribot E. (1989). "Alteration of proprioceptive messages induced by tendon vibration in man — a microneurographic study", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 76, 213222. [Crossref]
75. Roll J. P., Roll R., Velay J.-L. (1991). "Proprioception as a link between body space and extra-personal space", in: Brain and Space, Paillard J. (Ed.), pp.  112132. Oxford University Press, New York, NY, USA.
76. Roll J.-P., Albert F., Thyrion C., Ribot-Ciscar E., Bergenheim M., Mattei B. (2009). "Inducing any virtual two-dimensional movement in humans by applying muscle tendon vibration", J. Neurophysiol. Vol 101, 816823. [Crossref]
77. Roth M., Decety J., Raybaudi M., Massarelli R., Delon-Martin C., Segebarth C., Morand S., Gemignani A., Décorps M., Jeannerod M. (1996). "Possible involvement of primary motor cortex in mentally simulated movement: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study", Neuroreport Vol 7, 12801284. [Crossref]
78. Schofield J. S., Dawson M. R., Carey J. P., Hebert J. S. (2015). "Characterizing the effects of amplitude, frequency and limb position on vibration induced movement illusions: implications in sensory-motor rehabilitation", Technol. Health Care Vol 23, 129141.
79. Seizova-Cajic T., Azzi R. (2010). "A visual distracter task during adaptation reduces the proprioceptive movement aftereffect", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 203, 213219. [Crossref]
80. Seizova-Cajic T., Azzi R. (2011). "Conflict with vision diminishes proprioceptive adaptation to muscle vibration", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 211, 169175. [Crossref]
81. Seizova-Cajic T., Sachtler W. L. B. (2007). "Adaptation of a bimodal integration stage: visual input needed during neck muscle vibration to elicit a motion aftereffect", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 181, 117129. [Crossref]
82. Seizova-Cajic T., Sachtler W. L. B., Curthoys I. S. (2006). "Eye movements cannot explain vibration-induced visual motion and motion aftereffect", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 173, 141152. [Crossref]
83. Seizova-Cajic T., Smith J. L., Taylor J. L., Gandevia S. C. (2007). "Proprioceptive movement illusions due to prolonged stimulation: reversals and aftereffects", PLoS One Vol 2, e1037. DOI:. [Crossref]
84. Sibuya M., Yamada M., Kanamaru A., Tanaka K., Suzuki H., Noguchi E., Altose M. D., Homma I. (1994). "Effect of chest wall vibration on dyspnea in patients with chronic respiratory disease", Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med. Vol 149, 12351240. [Crossref]
85. Simons D. J., Chabris C. F. (1999). "Gorillas in our midst: sustained inattentional blindness for dynamic events", Perception Vol 28, 10591074. [Crossref]
86. Sittig A. C., Denier van der Gon J. J., Gielen C. C. (1985). "Separate control of arm position and velocity demonstrated by vibration of muscle tendon in man", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 60, 445453. [Crossref]
87. Sittig A. C., Denier van der Gon J. J., Gielen C. C. (1987). "The contribution of afferent information on position and velocity to the control of slow and fast human forearm movements", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 67, 3340. [Crossref]
88. Taylor J. L. (2013). "Kinesthetic inputs", in: Neuroscience in the 21st Century, Pfaff D. W. (Ed.), pp.  931964. Springer, New York, NY, USA. [Crossref]
89. Taylor J. L., McCloskey D. I. (1991). "Illusions of head and visual target displacement induced by vibration of neck muscles", Brain Vol 114 (Pt 2), 755759. [Crossref]
90. Thieme H., Mehrholz J., Pohl M., Behrens J., Dohle C. (2012). "Mirror therapy for improving motor function after stroke", Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. Vol 3, CD008449. DOI:.
91. Thyrion C., Roll J.-P. (2009). "Perceptual integration of illusory and imagined kinesthetic images", J. Neurosci. Vol 29, 84838492. [Crossref]
92. Tidoni E., Fusco G., Leonardis D., Frisoli A., Bergamasco M., Aglioti S. A. (2015). "Illusory movements induced by tendon vibration in right- and left-handed people", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 233, 375383. [Crossref]
93. Tsuge M., Izumizaki M., Kigawa K., Atsumi T., Homma I. (2012). "Interaction between vibration-evoked proprioceptive illusions and mirror-evoked visual illusions in an arm-matching task", Exp. Brain Res. Vol 223, 541551. [Crossref]
94. Vallbo A. B. (1970). "Discharge patterns in human muscle spindle afferents during isometric voluntary contractions", Acta Physiol. Scand. Vol 80, 552566. [Crossref]
95. Velay J. L., Roll J. P., Roll R., Lennerstrand G. (1994). "Eye proprioception and visual localization in humans: influence of ocular dominance and visual context", Vision Res. Vol 34, 21692176. [Crossref]
96. Volpe D., Giantin M. G., Fasano A. (2014). "A wearable proprioceptive stabilizer (Equistasi®) for rehabilitation of postural instability in Parkinson’s disease: a phase II randomized double-blind, double-dummy, controlled study", PLoS One Vol 9, e112065. DOI:. [Crossref]
97. Yao H.-Y., Hayward V. (2010). "Design and analysis of a recoil-type vibrotactile transducer", J. Acoust. Soc. Am. Vol 128, 619627. [Crossref]
http://brill.metastore.ingenta.com/content/journals/10.1163/22134808-00002544
Loading

Article metrics loading...

/content/journals/10.1163/22134808-00002544
2017-01-26
2018-10-15

Sign-in

Can't access your account?
  • Tools

  • Add to Favorites
  • Printable version
  • Email this page
  • Subscribe to ToC alert
  • Get permissions
  • Recommend to your library

    You must fill out fields marked with: *

    Librarian details
    Your details
    Why are you recommending this title?
    Select reason:
     
    Multisensory Research — Recommend this title to your library
  • Export citations
  • Key

  • Full access
  • Open Access
  • Partial/No accessInformation