Cookies Policy
X

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

I accept this policy

Find out more here

Cases as a New Source of Law in China?: Key Features of and Reflections on China’s Case Guidance System

No metrics data to plot.
The attempt to load metrics for this article has failed.
The attempt to plot a graph for these metrics has failed.
The full text of this article is not currently available.

Brill’s MyBook program is exclusively available on BrillOnline Books and Journals. Students and scholars affiliated with an institution that has purchased a Brill E-Book on the BrillOnline platform automatically have access to the MyBook option for the title(s) acquired by the Library. Brill MyBook is a print-on-demand paperback copy which is sold at a favorably uniform low price.

Access this article

+ Tax (if applicable)
Add to Favorites
You must be logged in to use this functionality

image of China Law and Society Review

In November 2010, the Supreme People’s Court of China introduced a new legal institution called the case guidance system, under which the Supreme People’s Court selects and publishes guiding cases, which are supposed to be followed by all courts when deciding later similar cases. The introduction of the case guidance system is an important step in the quest for better use of cases in China, where cases are formally rejected as a source of law. This paper provides an overview of the general design and functioning of the case guidance system. It also reflects on the limitations of the case guidance system and presents some initial thoughts on possible ways to further enhance the use of cases as a source of law in China.

Affiliations: 1: Houthoff Buruma w.guo@houthoff.com

10.1163/25427466-00101003
/content/journals/10.1163/25427466-00101003
dcterms_title,pub_keyword,dcterms_description,pub_author
10
5
Loading
Loading

Full text loading...

/content/journals/10.1163/25427466-00101003
Loading

Data & Media loading...

1. Ahl Björn. 2014. "Retaining judicial professionalism: The new guiding cases mechanism of the Supreme People’s Court". China Quarterly ,Vol 2014, no.217: 12139.
2. Alford William P.,, and Liebman Benjamin L.. 2001. "Clean air, clear process? The struggle over air pollution law in the People’s Republic of China." Hastings Law Journal Vol 52, 2001, no. 3:70348.
3. Cao Shouhua. 2010. "Anli zhidao, sifa zouchu tong’an butongpan [Case guidance, the judicature says farewell to the problem of like cases being decided differently]". Fazhi Ribao [Legal Daily], December 16, 2010.
4. Chen Canping. 2006. "Anli zhidao zhidu zhong caozuoxing nandian wenti tantao [Discussion of difficult practical issues concerning the case guidance system]". Faxue Zazhi [Law Science Magazine] ,Vol 2006, no. 3:1013.
5. Chen Dagang,, and Wei Qun,. 2004. "Lun panlifa fangfa zai woguo fazhi jianshe zhong de jiejian zuoyong [Implications of the method of case law for constructing China’s legal system]". In Panli zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Law Systems], ed. Wu Shuchen, 6880. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
6. Chen Guangzhong,, and Xie Zhengquan,. 2004. "Guanyu woguo jianli panli zhidu wenti de sikao [Reflections on a precedent system for China]". In Panli zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Law Systems], ed. Wu Shuchen, 12131. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
7. Chen Weidong,, and Li Xunhu. 2003. "Xianli panjue, panli zhidu, sifa gaige [Precedent judgment, case-law system and judicial reform]". Falu Shiyong [Application of Law], Vol 2003, no. 1:2024.
8. Chen Xingliang. 2012. Cong guize tixi shijiao kaocha zhongguo anli zhidao zhidu [China’s case guidance system from the perspective of rules system].
9. Chen Xingliang, ed. 2014. Zhongguo anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [Research on China’s case guidance system]. Beijing: Peking University Press.
10. Cheng Qingsong. 2012. "Panjueshu, qing geige shuofu de liyou [Court judgments, please give a convincing reason]". Dongfang Zaobao [Dengfang Daily], June 1, 2012.
11. Cong Yan. 2009. Sifa jieshi tizhi de guifan jiqi wanshan [Regularization and perfection of the judicial interpretation mechanism].
12. Deng Jinting. 2014a. Empirical research on the effects of China’s guiding cases. .
13. Deng Jinting. 2014b. A functional analysis of China’s guiding cases. .
14. Deng Jinting. 2015. "The guiding case system in Mainland China". Frontiers of Law in China Vol 3, 2015, no. 10:126.
15. Deng Xiuming. 2007. "Sifa panli jizhi de lixing sikao [Rational thinking of judicial adjudication mechanism]". Falu Shiyong [Application of Law], 2007, no. 11:3641.
16. Ding Haihu. 2008. "Woguo anli gongbu zhidu de shizheng kaocha ji qi qishi [An empirical investigation and its implications on China’s system of published cases]". Dangdai Faxue [Contemporary Law Review], Vol 2008, no. 7:14146.
17. Dou Yuqiao,, and Wang Jianhua. 2009. Zhongguo anli zhidao de fazhan yu xianshi yiyi [The evolution and the practical significance of China’s case guidance system]. . Accessed October 25, 2010.
18. Duan Luping. 2012. "Zhidaoxing anli shehui tuijian moshi chulun, yi zuigao renmin fayuan guanyu anli zhidao gongzuo de guiding weili [Initial thoughts on public recommendation for guiding cases, using the Supreme People’s Court’s provisions concerning work on guiding cases as an example]". Shehui Kexue Yanjiu [Studies of Social Sciences], Vol 2012, (5):10510.
19. Gao Tao,, and Cao Shouhua. 2010. "Jianchi nengdong sifa linian, tansuo anli zhidao zhidu [Uphold the ideal of judicial activism, explore the case guidance system]". Renmin Fayuanbao, DecemberVol 29, 2010.
20. Gao Zhen,. 2004. "Yunyong panlifa zhi wojian [On the use of case law]". In Panli zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Law Systems], ed. Wu Shuchen, 1015. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
21. Gechlik Mei,, Phillips Dimitri,, and Lee Oma. 2014. Survey of judges in China (2013–2014). .
22. Gechlik Mei,, Zhang Minmin,, and Ye Liyi. 2016. Cumulative analysis of all subsequent cases referring to guiding cases in China (2014 Q1–2015 Q4). .
23. Guiding Cases Research Group of China Law Info. 2015. Zuigao renmin fayuan zhidaoxing anli sifa yingyong niandu baogao [Annual report on the application of the Supreme People’s Court’s guiding cases in adjudication]. .
24. Guo Feng,, Wu Guangxia,, and Li Bing. 2015. "Guanyu anli zhidao gongzuo de guiding shishi xize de lijie yu shiyong [Interpretation and application of the detailed implementation rules on the provisions of the Supreme People’s Court concerning work on case guidance]". Renmin Sifa: Yingyong [People’s Judicature: Application], Vol 2015, no. 17:3036.
25. Guo William Jing. 2015. From Case to Law: A Study on How Cases Fulfil the Role of a Source of Law in the Netherlands and Its Implications for China and Comparative Law . Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
26. Hart H.L.A. 1961. The Concept of Law . Oxford: Clarendon Press.
27. He Weifang. 2006. "Fu huxia boshi, zaitan panjueshu shangwang shi [A reply to Dr. Hu Xia, discussion online publication of court judgments again]". .
28. Higher People’s Court of Guangdong Province. 2008. "Guangdong sheng gaoji renmin fayuan shenpan weiyuanhui gongzuo guiding [Working rules of the Adjudication Committee of the higher People’s Court of Guangdong Province]". .
29. Higher People’s Court of Jilin Province. 2015. "Zuigaofa zhaokai fabuhui tongbao anli zhidao gongzuo qingkuang [The Supreme People’s Court holds a press conference regarding the work of case guidance]". .
30. Hou Meng. 2008. "Zuigao renmin fayuan niandu fenxi baogao [Analytical report on the Supreme People’s Court’s Work in 2007]". Falu Shiyong [Application of Law], Vol 2008, no. 5:2733.
31. Hu Yunteng,, and Tongzhi Yu., 2009. "Anli zhidao zhidu ruogan zhongda yinan zhengyi wenti yanjiu [A study of several important, difficult and controversial issues on the case guidance system]". In Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [A Study of the Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics], ed. Deyong Shen, 245. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
32. Hu Yunteng,, Luo Dongchuan,, Wang Yanbin,, and Liu Shaoyang. 2011. "Guanyu anli zhidao gongzuo de guiding de lijie yu shiyong [Interpretation and application of the provisions of the Supreme People’s Court concerning work on case guidance]". Renmin Sifa: Yingyong [People’s Judicature: Application], 2011, no. 3:3337.
33. Huang Xiaoyun. 2011. "Xuezhe, lushi reyi guanyu anli zhidao gongzuo de guiding [Scholars and lawyers discussing the Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court concerning work on guiding cases]". .
34. Human Rights First. 1996. "Opening to reform? An analysis of China’s revised Criminal Procedure Law". .
35. Intermediate People’s Court of Zhengzhou City. 2003. "Zhengzhou shi zhongji renmin fayuan shenpan weiyuanhui gongzuo guize [Working rules of the Adjudication Committee of the Intermediate People’s Court of Zhengzhou City]". .
36. Jia Mark. 2016. "Chinese common law? Guiding cases and judicial reform". Harvard Law Review , Vol 2016, no. 2213.
37. Jiang Anjie. 2011. "Anli zhidao zhidu guiding: Yige juyou huashidai yiyi de biaozhi [Provisions on case guidance system, a symbol of epochmaking significance]". Fazhi Ribao [Legal Daily], January 5, 2011.
38. Jiang Huiling. 2004. "Jianli anli zhidao zhidu de jige juti wenti [Several concrete issues on the creation of case guidance system]". Falu Shiyong [Journal of Law Application], Vol 2004, 5:812.
39. Keith Ronald,, and Lin Zhiqiu. 2009. "Judicial interpretation of China’s Supreme People’s Court as secondary law with special reference to criminal law". China Information ,Vol 2009, no. 23:22355.
40. Kühn Zdenek,. 2007. "Precedent in the Czech Republic". In Precedent and the Law , ed. Hondius E., 37196. Brussels: Bruylant.
41. Li Jiping. 2011. "Zhidaoxing anli falu xiaoli de gefang guandian [Various views on the force of guiding cases]". Fazhi Ribao [Legal Daily], January 5, 2011.
42. Li Ling,. 2010. "Corruption in China’s courts". In Judicial Independence in China, Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion , ed. Peerenboom Randall, 196220. Cambridge, uk: Cambridge University Press.
43. Li Shaoping,. 2009a. "Goujian anli zhidao zhidu zhi shijian yu sikao [Practices to create a case guidance system and reflections upon such practices]". In Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics], ed. Shen Deyong, 8593. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
44. Li Shichun. 2009b. "Anli zhidao zhidu de lingyitiao silu [An alternative perspective on the case guidance system]". Legal Science Monthly , Vol 2009, no. 6:5977.
45. Liu Yan,. 2009. "Zhidaoxing anli de tuixuan yu fabu chengxu yanjiu [On the selection and publication of guiding cases]". In Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics], ed. Shen Deyong, 10513. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
46. Liu Zuoxiang. 2007. "Ying yunxu yong anli duanan [Judges should be allowed to decide cases according to precedents]". Minzhu yu Fazhi [Democracy and Legal System], Vol 2007, 1:3233.
47. Liu Zuoxiang. 2015. "Zhongguo anli zhidao zhidu de zuixin jinzhan jiqi wenti [Latest developments and issues of China’s case guidance system]". Dongfang Faxue [Oriental Legal Science], Vol 2015, no. 3:3946.
48. Liu Zuoxiang,, and Jinghe Xu. 2006. "Anli zhidao zhidu de lilun jichu [Theoretical foundations of the case guidance system]". Faxue Yanjiu [Chinese Journal of Law], Vol 2006, 3:1629.
49. Lu Yun. 2011. "Anli zhidao zhidu lilun yu shijian yantaohui zhaokai [Seminar on theory and practice of the case guidance system]". .
50. Ma Fang,, and Cha Biran. 2011. "Difang fayuan tuixing anli zhidao zhidu de biyaoxing ji lujing xuanze [The necessity and possible ways for local courts to establish case guidance system]". Guanghua Faxue , 2011, no. 1:5971.
51. Office for Work on Case Guidance. 2014a. "Shanghai zhongyuan wuye guwen youxian gongsi su tao dehua jujian hetong jiufen an de lijie yu canzhao [Understanding and application of Shanghai Centaline Property Consultants Limited v. tao Dehua, an intermediation contract dispute]". Renmin Sifa: Anli [People’s Judicature: Cases], Vol 2014, no. 6:57.
52. Office for Work on Case Guidance. 2014b. "Wu Mei su Sichuan meishan xicheng zhiye youxian gongsi maimai hetong jiufen an de lijie yu canzhao [Understanding and application of Wu Mei v. Meishan Xicheng Paper Co., Ltd., of Sichuan Province, a sale and purchase contract dispute]". Renmin Sifa: Anli [People’s Judicature: Cases], Vol 2014, no. 6:911.
53. Qin Wang., 2007. "Lun woguo anli zhidao zhidu de goujian he shiyong fangfa [On the creation and operation of the case guidance system]". In Falu fangfa yu falu siwei [Legal Method and Legal Thinking], ed. Ge Hongyi, 205221. Beijing: Falu chubanshe.
54. Rao Lili,, and Liao Yunqian,. 2009. "Guanyu shixing anli zhidao zhidu de diaoyan baogao [Research report on the implementation of the case guidance system]". In Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [A Study of the Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics], ed. Shen Deyong, 11422. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
55. Research Department of the Supreme People’s Court, ed. 2007. Shenpan qianyan wenti yanjiu [Research on Adjudication Frontier Issues]. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
56. Research Group of the Editor’s Office of People’s Court Daily. 2007. "Anli zhidao zhidu de diaoyan baogao [Research report on the case guidance system]". In Shenpan qianyan wenti yanjiu [Research on Adjudication Frontier Issues], ed. Research Department of the Supreme People’s Court, 46583. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
57. Shen Deyong,. 2009a. "Yi qiuzhen wushi he gaige chuangxin jingshen tansuo jianli zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu [Exploring a case guidance system with Chinese characteristics in the spirit of seeking truth and carrying out innovative reform]". In Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics], ed. Shen Deyong, 37. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
58. Shen Deyong, ed. 2009b. Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [Research on a Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics]. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
59. Shen Fu., 2004. "Shilun panli ye yingdang chengwei woguo de falu yuanyuan [Cases should also become a source of law in china]". In Panli zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Law Systems], ed. Wu Shuchen, 1823. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
60. Shen Zhixian,, Liu Li,, and Fan Lihong,. 2009. "Zhongji renmin fayuan fahui anli zhidao zuoyong de tansuo yu sikao [Experiments by middle people’s courts to explore the use of case guidance system and reflections upon such experiments]". In Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics], ed. Shen Deyong, 94104. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
61. Su Zelin,, and Li Xuan. 2009. "Lun sifa tongyi yu anli zhidao zhidu de wanshan [On the perfection of judicial unity and the case guidance system]". Zhongguo sifa [Justice of China], Vol 2009, 12:1216.
62. Sun Yanxin. 2011. "Zhongguo faxue jiaoyu luanxiang [Chaos in China’s legal education]".
63. Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China. 2005. "Renmin fayuan di’erge wunian gaige gangyao [Second five-year reform outline of the people’s courts]". . Accessed October 25, 2010.
64. Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China. 2015. "Zuigao renmin fayuan guanyu anli zhidao gongzuo de guiding shishi xize [Detailed implementation rules on the provisions of the Supreme People’s Court concerning work on case guidance]".
65. Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China. 2016. "Zuigao renmin fayuan gongzuo baogao [Work report of the Supreme People’s Court]". .
66. Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China. 1993. "Zuigao renmin fayuan shenpan weiyuanhui gongzuo guize [Working rules of the Adjudication Committee of the Supreme People’s Court)]". .
67. Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China. 2010a. "Renmin fayuan liangxing zhidao yijiang [Opinions on sentencing guidance for people’s courts]". .
68. Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China. 2010b. "Zuigao renmin fayuan guanyu anli zhidao gongzuo de guiding [Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court concerning work on guiding cases]". .
69. Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China. 2010c. "Zuigao renmin fayuan guanyu gaige he wanshan renmin fayuan shepan weiyuanhui zhidu de shishi yijian [Opinions of the Supreme People’s Court on the reform and improvement of the insitution of Adjudication Committee]". .
70. Tsia Tao-tai,, and Zeldin Wendy. 1987. "Recent Legal Development in the People’s Republic of China". Harvard International Law Journal Vol 2, 1987, no. 28:24987.
71. Van Rooij B. 2004. "Falü de weidu, cong kongjianshang jiedu falü shibai [Law’s dimension, understanding legal failure spatially]. (Trans. Yao Yan)". Sixiang Zhanxian [Thinking], Vol 2004, 4:10917.
72. Van Rooij Benjamin. 2006. Regulating Land and Pollution in China, Lawmaking, Compliance and Enforcement; Theory and Cases . Leiden: Leiden University Press.
73. Wan Yi. 2005. "Lishi yu xianshi jiaokun zhong de anjian qingshi zhidu [Case guidance seeking, a perplexing institution in history and reality]". Faxue [Legal Science], Vol 2005, 2:918.
74. Wang Liming. 2012a. "Chengwenfa chuantong zhong de chuangxin, zenme kan anli zhidao zhidu [Innovation in a tradition of codification, how to understand the case guidance system]". . Accessed June 19, 2012.
75. Wang Liming. 2012b. "Woguo anli zhidao zhidu ruogan wenti yanjiu [Research on several issues regarding the case guidance system of our country]". Faxue [Legal Science], Vol 2012, no. 1:7180.
76. Wang Lin. 2008. "Sifa jieshi geng xuyao jieshi [Judicial interpretations need more interpretation]". .
77. Wang Lin. 2009. "Yuan anli zhidao zhidu zhongjie tongan bu tongpan [May the case guidance system cure the problem of like cases being decided differently]". Dongfang Zaobao [Dongfang Daily], March 12, 2009.
78. Wang Zhiqiang. 2005. "Case Precedent in Qing China: Rethinking Traditional Case Law". Columbia Journal of Asian Law Vol 1, 2005, no. 19:32344.
79. Wu Shuchen, ed. 2004. Panli zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Law Systems]. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
80. Wu Yingzi. 2011. "Anli zhidao zhidu neng zou duoyuan? [How far can the case guidance system go?]". Jiangsu Daxue Xuebao [Jiangsu University Journal] ,Vol 2011, 4:3237.
81. Xu Cailiao,. 2004. "Ying jianli you zhongguo tese de panli zhidu [A system of precedents with Chinese characteristics should be established]". In Panli zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Law Systems], ed. Wu Shuchen, 35. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
82. Xu Xin. 2009. "Maixiang sifa tongyi de anli zhidao zhidu [A case guidance system that marches toward a uniform administration of justice]". Xuexi yu Tansuo [Study & Exploration], 2009, no. Vol 5:15764.
83. Yan Quanshui,. 2009. "Guanyu jianli juyou zhongguo tese de anli zhidao zhidu de sikao [Reflections on the creation of a case guidance system with Chinese characteristics]". In Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [A Study of the Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics], ed. Shen Deyong, 13945. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
84. Yuan Xiuting. 2009. "Woguo anli zhidao zhidu de shijian yunzuo ji qi pingxi, yi zuigao renmin fayuan gongbao zhong de zhishi chanquan anli wei duixiang [Evaluation of the operation of China’s case guidance system, a study of the intellectual property cases published in the Supreme People’s Courts gazette]". Fashang Yanjiu [Studies in Business and Law], Vol 2009, no. 2:1029.
85. Zhang Dongbo,. 2009. "Jianli anli zhidao zhidu de shizheng baogao [Empirical report on the creation of a case guidance system]". In Zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu yanjiu [A Study of the Case Guidance System with Chinese Characteristics], ed. Shen Deyong, 12338. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
86. Zhang Qi. 2002. "Panlifa de bijiao yanjiu [A comparative study on case law]". Bijiaofa Yanjiu [Comparative Law Research], Vol 2002, 4:7994.
87. Zhang Qi. 2004. "Jianli Zhongguo xianli zhidu de yiyi yu lujing, jianda panlifa zhiyi [The significance and approach to establish precedent system in China, A response to oppugning case law]". Fazhi yu Shehui Fazhan [Law and Social Development] ,Vol 2004, no. 6:98114.
88. Zhang Qi. 2013. "Rediscussion of the nature of validity and guarantee concerning the effects of guiding cases". Peking University Law Journal 2, 2013, no. Vol 1:25986.
89. Zhang Richard Junqi. 2014. "Ex post v. ex ante: From the perspective of China". .
90. Zhang Xianming. 2011. "Yonghao yonghuo zhidaoxing anli, nuli shixian sifa gongzheng, zuigao renmin fayuan yuanjiushi fuzeren jiu anli zhidao zhidu da jizhe wen [Using guiding cases well to achieve justice in adjudication, chief of the Research Department of the Supreme People’s Court answers questions raised by a reporter]". Renmin Fayuanbao [People’s Court Daily], December 21, 2011.
91. Zhao Lei. 2009a. "Tongan tongpan shi yige shenhua? [Is having like cases being treated alike a fairy tale?]". Nanfang Zhoumo [Southern Weekly], September 3, 2009.
92. Zhao Wen,, and Liu Peisen. 2004. "Guanyu jianli panli zhidu de jidian sikao [Several thoughts on establishing a system of precedents]". In Panli zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Law Systems], 53339. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
93. Zhao Xucheng. 2009b. "Qinghua daxue faxueyuan jiaoshou Zhang Weiping: anjian qingshi youwei fazhi ying quxiao [Tsinghua Law School Professor Zhang Weiping: The practice of seeking guidance in trials is not in conformity with the rule of law and should be abolished]". Xin Jing Bao , May 16, 2009.
94. Zhou Bin. 2011. "Sanwei dafaguan changtan zhongguo tese anli zhidao zhidu [Three senior judges discussing case guidance system with Chinese characteristics]". Fazhi Ribao [Legal Daily], May 13, 2011.
95. Zong Yuan. 2009. "Cong linshixing qiangjian kan panjueshu shuoli [Temporary rape and legal reasoning in court judgments]". Jiancha Ribao [Procuratorial Daily], November 4, 2009.
96. Zuo Tengyu,. 2004. "Shilun panli zai woguo falu yuanyuan zhongde diwei [On the status of cases as a source of law in China]". In Panli zhidu yanjiu [Research on Case Law Systems], ed. Wu Shuchen, 98100. Beijing: Renmin fayuan chubanshe.
http://brill.metastore.ingenta.com/content/journals/10.1163/25427466-00101003
Loading

Article metrics loading...

/content/journals/10.1163/25427466-00101003
2016-05-16
2017-11-24

Sign-in

Can't access your account?
  • Tools

  • Add to Favorites
  • Printable version
  • Email this page
  • Subscribe to ToC alert
  • Get permissions
  • Recommend to your library

    You must fill out fields marked with: *

    Librarian details
    Your details
    Why are you recommending this title?
    Select reason:
     
    China Law and Society Review — Recommend this title to your library
  • Export citations
  • Key

  • Full access
  • Open Access
  • Partial/No accessInformation